arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2601.12690cs.HC
收藏

我们在这里是在为斯波克写建议专栏吗?理解为自闭症用户提供的AI建议中的刻板印象

"Are we writing an advice column for Spock here?" Understanding Stereotypes in AI Advice for Autistic Users

Virginia Tech(弗吉尼亚理工大学);NAVER AI Lab(Naver人工智能实验室)

Caleb Wohn, Buse Çarık, Xiaohan Ding, Sang Won Lee, Young-Ho Kim, Eugenia H. Rho

AI总结:

研究探讨了自闭症用户在请求AI建议时披露身份对建议生成的影响,发现LLM在披露身份时更倾向于避免刻板印象情境,引发对个性化建议有效性的讨论。

摘要:

自闭症个体有时在请求大语言模型(LLM)提供社交建议时披露自闭症身份,希望获得更个性化的回应。然而,他们也意识到这些系统可能会复制刻板印象,从而对披露的风险和益处产生不确定性。我们进行了一项混合方法研究,结合了大规模的LLM审计实验和涉及11名自闭症参与者访谈。我们开发了一个六步流程,将12个已记录的自闭症刻板印象转化为决策场景,这些场景被框架为用户请求建议(例如,“我应该做A还是B?”)。我们从六个LLM生成了345,000条回应,并测量了当提示披露自闭症身份与不披露时建议如何变化。当披露自闭症身份时,LLM倾向于不成比例地推荐避免刻板印象压力情境,包括社交活动、对抗性场合、新经历和浪漫关系。尽管一些参与者认为这具有肯定性,但其他人批评这会婴儿化或削弱成长的机会。我们的研究揭示了肯定与刻板印象交织如何使LLM的个性化变得复杂。

英文摘要:

Autistic individuals sometimes disclose autism when asking LLMs for social advice, hoping for more personalized responses. However, they also recognize that these systems may reproduce stereotypes, raising uncertainty about the risks and benefits of disclosure. We conducted a mixed-methods study combining a large-scale LLM audit experiment with interviews involving 11 autistic participants. We developed a six-step pipeline operationalizing 12 documented autism stereotypes into decision-making scenarios framed as users requesting advice (e.g., "Should I do A or B?"). We generated 345,000 responses from six LLMs and measured how advice shifted when prompts disclosed autism versus when they did not. When autism was disclosed, LLMs disproportionately recommended avoiding stereotypically stressful situations, including social events, confrontations, new experiences, and romantic relationships. While some participants viewed this as affirming, others criticized it as infantilizing or undermining opportunities for growth. Our study illuminates how the intermingling of affirmation and stereotyping complicates the personalization of LLMs.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑