镜中架构:在幻象中评估生成图像模型对建筑风格、元素和类型学的再现能力
Architecture inside the mirage: evaluating generative image models on architectural style, elements, and typologies
AI总结:
评估生成图像模型在建筑风格、元素和类型学上的准确性,发现常见提示生成的图像更准确,但整体准确性有限,需加强标注和教育使用。
摘要:
生成式人工智能(GenAI)的文本到图像系统日益被用于生成建筑图像,但其在受历史规则约束的领域中准确再现图像的能力仍缺乏充分的表征。我们评估了五个广泛使用的GenAI图像平台(Adobe Firefly、DALL-E 3、Google Imagen 3、Microsoft Image Generator和Midjourney),使用30个涵盖风格、类型学和编码元素的建筑提示。每个提示生成器对生成四张图像(总计600张图像)。两位建筑史学家独立地根据预定义的标准对每张图像进行准确性评分,并通过共识解决分歧。集级性能总结为每四张图像集中有零到四张准确图像。常见提示生成的图像准确性是罕见提示的2.7倍(p < 0.05)。在不同平台中,整体准确性有限(最高准确性得分为52百分比;最低为32百分比;平均为42百分比)。所有正确(4/4)的结果在不同平台之间相似。相比之下,所有错误(0/4)的结果差异显著,Imagen 3表现出最少的错误,而Microsoft Image Generator表现出最多的错误。对图像数据集的定性审查识别出反复出现的模式,包括过度装饰、中世纪风格与其后来复兴的混淆,以及对描述性提示的误表征(例如,蛋形装饰、带状柱、悬挂式拱顶)。这些发现支持了对GenAI合成内容进行明显标注的必要性,未来训练数据集的来源标准,以及对GenAI建筑图像的谨慎教育使用。
英文摘要:
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) text-to-image systems are increasingly used to generate architectural imagery, yet their capacity to reproduce accurate images in a historically rule-bound field remains poorly characterized. We evaluated five widely used GenAI image platforms (Adobe Firefly, DALL-E 3, Google Imagen 3, Microsoft Image Generator, and Midjourney) using 30 architectural prompts spanning styles, typologies, and codified elements. Each prompt-generator pair produced four images (n = 600 images total). Two architectural historians independently scored each image for accuracy against predefined criteria, resolving disagreements by consensus. Set-level performance was summarized as zero to four accurate images per four-image set. Image output from Common prompts was 2.7-fold more accurate than from Rare prompts (p < 0.05). Across platforms, overall accuracy was limited (highest accuracy score 52 percent; lowest 32 percent; mean 42 percent). All-correct (4 out of 4) outcomes were similar across platforms. By contrast, all-incorrect (0 out of 4) outcomes varied substantially, with Imagen 3 exhibiting the fewest failures and Microsoft Image Generator exhibiting the highest number of failures. Qualitative review of the image dataset identified recurring patterns including over-embellishment, confusion between medieval styles and their later revivals, and misrepresentation of descriptive prompts (for example, egg-and-dart, banded column, pendentive). These findings support the need for visible labeling of GenAI synthetic content, provenance standards for future training datasets, and cautious educational use of GenAI architectural imagery.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。