arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2601.03182math.OC
收藏

主观-客观中位数重要性技术(SOMIT)用于多准则可再生能源评估

Subjective-Objective Median-based Importance Technique (SOMIT) to Aid Multi-Criteria Renewable Energy Evaluation

Singapore University of Social Sciences(新加坡社会科学大学)

Ding Ding, Yang Li, Poh Ling Neo, Zhiyuan Wang, Chongwu Xia

AI总结:

SOMIT是一种结合主观和客观方法的新技术,用于确定多准则决策中的标准权重,以提升可再生能源评估的准确性和效率。

摘要:

加速可再生能源转型需要做出有信息的决策,以考虑不同可再生能源技术在财务、技术、环境和社会方面的各种权衡。在这一多准则决策(MCDM)过程中,确定适当的标准权重是一个关键步骤。然而,推导这些权重往往仅涉及决策者主观评估或客观加权方法,每种方法在认知负担、潜在偏见和不足的上下文相关性方面都有局限性。本研究提出了主观-客观中位数重要性技术(SOMIT),一种新的混合方法,用于确定MCDM中的标准权重。通过将SOMIT专门应用于可再生能源评估,该方法直接支持应用能源系统规划、政策分析和技术优先级设定,以实现碳中和目标。SOMIT的实用性通过两个MCDM案例研究得到验证,这些研究涉及印度和沙特阿拉伯的可再生能源决策。使用从SOMIT推导出的权重,TOPSIS方法对可再生能源替代方案进行排名,太阳能在两种情况下均获得最高性能分数。本工作的主要贡献有五个方面:1)所提出的SOMIT将所需的主观比较次数从传统二次顺序减少到线性顺序;2)SOMIT在替代-标准矩阵(ACM)中对异常值更具鲁棒性;3)SOMIT平衡了主观专家知识与客观数据驱动的洞察,从而减轻偏见;4)SOMIT本质上是模块化的,允许其各个部分和整个方法无缝耦合到广泛应用于能源系统和政策分析的MCDM方法中;5)为SOMIT开发了一个专门的Python库,pysomit。

英文摘要:

Accelerating the renewable energy transition requires informed decision-making that accounts for the diverse financial, technical, environmental, and social trade-offs across different renewable energy technologies. A critical step in this multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) process is the determination of appropriate criteria weights. However, deriving these weights often solely involves either subjective assessment from decision-makers or objective weighting methods, each of which has limitations in terms of cognitive burden, potential bias, and insufficient contextual relevance. This study proposes the subjective-objective median-based importance technique (SOMIT), a novel hybrid approach for determining criteria weights in MCDM. By tailoring SOMIT to renewable energy evaluation, the method directly supports applied energy system planning, policy analysis, and technology prioritization under carbon neutrality goals. The practical utility of SOMIT is demonstrated through two MCDM case studies on renewable energy decision-making in India and Saudi Arabia. Using the derived weights from SOMIT, the TOPSIS method ranks the renewable energy alternatives, with solar power achieving the highest performance scores in both cases. The main contributions of this work are five-fold: 1) the proposed SOMIT reduces the number of required subjective comparisons from the conventional quadratic order to a linear order; 2) SOMIT is more robust to outliers in the alternatives-criteria matrix (ACM); 3) SOMIT balances subjective expert knowledge with objective data-driven insights, thereby mitigating bias; 4) SOMIT is inherently modular, allowing both its individual parts and the complete approach to be seamlessly coupled with a wide range of MCDM methods commonly applied in energy systems and policy analysis; 5) a dedicated Python library, pysomit, is developed for SOMIT.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑