arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2512.17005econ.EMstat.ME
收藏

结构动态模型的原理性识别

Principled Identification of Structural Dynamic Models

University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill(北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校);Xiamen University(厦门大学)

Neville Francis, Peter Reinhard Hansen, Chen Tong

AI总结:

本文提出一种基于优化目标的结构动态模型识别方法,通过Order-和Scale-不变方案(OASIS)选择与目标变量最一致的正交旋转,改进了传统SVAR的递归Cholesky识别方法,并在代理VAR中提供新的估计策略。

摘要:

我们从新视角出发,对结构动态模型的识别进行了研究:不是仅施加限制,而是优化一个目标。尽管最终的结构识别需要外生经济洞察,但一个加权相关性最大化的目标产生了一个Order-和Scale-不变方案(OASIS),它选择与指定目标变量最一致的正交旋转。在传统SVAR中,这些目标是简化形式的创新,使得OASIS成为自然的参考旋转。我们显示递归Cholesky识别是该目标的约束版本,并且OASIS在理论上和经验上都更接近完美相关性,闭合的差距大约是递归顺序的两倍。相同的框架也提供了代理VAR(IV-SVAR)的原理性估计策略,其中加权标准对于解决多代理系统中的过度确定性至关重要,同时对称地处理代理泄漏。重新审视22个已发表的SVAR,我们发现简化形式的创新通常只有弱相关性,这有助于解释递归方案的历史稳健性。然而,将OASIS应用于经典代理应用,却揭示了冲击间的经济重要泄漏,并显示考虑此类泄漏可以实质性地改变实质性结论。

英文摘要:

We take a new perspective on identification in structural dynamic models: rather than imposing restrictions alone, we optimize an objective. While definitive structural identification ultimately requires exogenous economic insight, a weighted correlation-maximizing objective yields an Order- and Scale-Invariant Scheme (OASIS) that selects the orthogonal rotation most aligned with designated target variables. In traditional SVARs, these targets are the reduced-form innovations, making OASIS a natural reference rotation. We show that recursive Cholesky identification is a constrained version of the same objective and that OASIS is systematically closer to perfect correlation, closing roughly twice as much of the gap as recursive orderings, both theoretically and empirically. The same framework also provides a principled estimation strategy for Proxy VARs (IV-SVARs), where the weighted criterion is essential for resolving overdetermination in multi-proxy systems while symmetrically accommodating proxy leakage. Revisiting 22 published SVARs, we find that reduced-form innovations are typically only weakly correlated, helping explain the historical robustness of recursive schemes. Applying OASIS to seminal proxy applications, however, reveals economically important leakage across shocks and shows that accounting for such leakage can materially alter substantive conclusions.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑