We take a new perspective on identification in structural dynamic models: rather than imposing restrictions alone, we optimize an objective. While definitive structural identification ultimately requires exogenous economic insight, a weighted correlation-maximizing objective yields an Order- and Scale-Invariant Scheme (OASIS) that selects the orthogonal rotation most aligned with designated target variables. In traditional SVARs, these targets are the reduced-form innovations, making OASIS a natural reference rotation. We show that recursive Cholesky identification is a constrained version of the same objective and that OASIS is systematically closer to perfect correlation, closing roughly twice as much of the gap as recursive orderings, both theoretically and empirically. The same framework also provides a principled estimation strategy for Proxy VARs (IV-SVARs), where the weighted criterion is essential for resolving overdetermination in multi-proxy systems while symmetrically accommodating proxy leakage. Revisiting 22 published SVARs, we find that reduced-form innovations are typically only weakly correlated, helping explain the historical robustness of recursive schemes. Applying OASIS to seminal proxy applications, however, reveals economically important leakage across shocks and shows that accounting for such leakage can materially alter substantive conclusions.
University of Bologna(博洛尼亚大学);Brown University(布朗大学);University of Milan(米兰大学);Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei(埃尼·恩里科·马泰伊基金会);Study Center Gerzensee, Foundation of the Swiss National Bank(瑞士国家银行Gerzensee研究中心)
Identification and Auto-debiased Machine Learning for Outcome Conditioned Average Structural Derivatives
本文在一般不可分模型中提出了一类新的异质因果量,称为\textit{outcome conditioned}平均结构导数(OASD)。OASD是连续治疗中边际变化对位于结果分布不同部分的个体的平均部分效应,而与个体的特征无关。OASD结合了ATE和QTE的两个特征:它被直接解释为ATE,同时通过根据结局分布的等级将整个人群分解,比ATE更细粒度。本文的一个贡献是,我们建立了一些密切的关系之间的\textit{outcome conditioned average partial effects}和一类参数测量的影响,反事实改变一个单一的协变量的分布上的无条件的结果分位数。利用这种关系,我们可以得到根$n$一致估计,并计算这些反事实效应参数的半参数效率界。我们通过两个例子来说明这一点:OASD和无条件偏分位数效应之间的等价性(Firpo et al.(2009)),以及边际偏分布政策效应(Rothe(2012))和相应的结果条件参数之间的等价性。由于OASD的识别是在条件外生性假设下实现的,通过控制关于协变量的丰富信息,研究人员可以理想地在数据中使用高维控制。提出了一种新的自动去偏机器学习估计器,并给出了它的渐近统计保证,证明了该估计器是根$n$相容的、渐近正态的和半参数有效的.我们还证明了引导程序的有效性的OASD过程的一致推理。