分析有关青少年在线安全功能的社交媒体声明以确定问题领域和沟通缺口
Analyzing Social Media Claims regarding Youth Online Safety Features to Identify Problem Areas and Communication Gaps
AI总结:
本研究分析了社交媒体平台关于青少年在线安全功能的声明,揭示了沟通中的问题领域和不一致之处,提出了改进透明度的建议。
摘要:
社交媒体平台在是否以及如何保护青少年在线方面面临越来越多的质疑。尽管关于儿童在线风险的先前研究已经很详尽,但社交媒体平台如何沟通这些风险以及他们改进青少年安全的努力尚未得到全面考察。为了填补这一空白,我们分析了2019年至2024年间由四个以青少年为主的平台发布的N=352份新闻简报和安全相关博客,这四个平台分别是YouTube、TikTok、Meta(Facebook和Instagram)以及Snapchat。通过归纳和演绎性的定性方法,我们开发了一个涵盖七个问题领域风险出现的综合框架,以及社交媒体平台声称解决这些风险的安全功能分类法。我们的分析揭示了问题领域上的不均衡强调,大多数沟通集中在内容暴露和人际沟通上,而对内容创作、数据访问和平台访问则较少强调。此外,我们还识别了三种与所描述的安全功能相关的有问题的沟通实践,包括功能实施与可用性之间的差异、对安全功能操作的解释不清楚或不一致,以及缺乏关于安全功能在实施后减轻风险有效性证据。基于这些发现,我们讨论了风险与所描述的安全功能之间的沟通缺口,以及在实现平台沟通透明性方面的张力。我们对平台沟通的分析为负责任地沟通青少年安全功能提供了指南。
英文摘要:
Social media platforms have faced increasing scrutiny over whether and how they protect youth online. While online risks to children have been well-documented by prior research, how social media platforms communicate about these risks and their efforts to improve youth safety have not been holistically examined. To fill this gap, we analyzed N=352 press releases and safety-related blogs published between 2019 and 2024 by four platforms popular among youth: YouTube, TikTok, Meta (Facebook and Instagram), and Snapchat. Leveraging both inductive and deductive qualitative approaches, we developed a comprehensive framework of seven problem areas where risks arise, and a taxonomy of safety features that social media platforms claim address these risks. Our analysis revealed uneven emphasis across problem areas, with most communications focused on Content Exposure and Interpersonal Communication, whereas less emphasis was placed on Content Creation, Data Access, and Platform Access. Additionally, we identified three problematic communication practices related to their described safety features, including discrepancies between feature implementation and availability, unclear or inconsistent explanations of safety feature operation, and a lack of evidence regarding the effectiveness of safety features in mitigating risks once implemented. Based on these findings, we discuss the communication gaps between risks and the described safety features, as well as the tensions in achieving transparency in platform communication. Our analysis of platform communication informs guidelines for responsibly communicating about youth safety features.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。