arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2512.14716physics.soc-ph
收藏

失真压力:组织信息环境中的选择动态

Dysmemic Pressure: Selection Dynamics in Organizational Information Environments

Jeremy McEntire

AI总结:

本文提出失真压力机制,解释组织为何陷入集体幻觉,并通过案例研究展示其运作,指出传统干预措施的失效原因。

摘要:

为什么由智能个体组成的组织会陷入集体幻觉?本文引入了失真压力作为一种正式机制,用以解释组织知识失败。综合战略沟通理论(Crawford & Sobel, 1982)、代理理论(Prendergast, 1993)和文化进化(Boyd & Richerson, 1985),我展示了组织代理之间的偏好分歧如何生成稳定的均衡状态,其中沟通在统计上与现实独立,而传输偏见将功能障碍锁定在自我强化的状态中。该机制通过可识别的动力学运作:随着发送者和接收者偏好之间的偏见增加,沟通精度通过逐渐粗化的分区下降,直到达到“babbling均衡”状态,其中信息不再携带任何内容;同时,传输偏见(内容、声望、从众)确保了功能障碍信号在组织 memes 中胜过准确信号。三个详细的案例研究——诺基亚智能手机崩溃、挑战者号航天飞机灾难和富国银行账户欺诈丑闻——展示了该机制在不同行业和失败模式中的运作。我推导出五个可检验的命题,并通过机制设计的视角评估潜在的对策。分析将组织功能障碍从道德失败重新界定为物理问题,解释了为什么标准干预(文化变革、领导力发展、价值观对齐)往往失败:它们将均衡结果视为行为问题,而非改变产生它们的选择环境。

英文摘要:

Why do organizations comprised of intelligent individuals converge on collective delusion? This paper introduces dysmemic pressure as a formal mechanism explaining organizational epistemic failure. Synthesizing strategic communication theory (Crawford & Sobel, 1982), agency theory (Prendergast, 1993), and cultural evolution (Boyd & Richerson, 1985), I demonstrate how preference divergence between organizational agents generates stable equilibria where communication becomes statistically independent of reality, while transmission biases lock dysfunction into self-reinforcing states. The mechanism operates through identifiable dynamics: as the bias between sender and receiver preferences increases, communication precision degrades through progressively coarser partitions until reaching "babbling equilibrium" where messages carry no information; simultaneously, transmission biases (content, prestige, conformity) ensure that dysfunctional signals outcompete accurate ones in the organizational meme pool. Three detailed case studies--Nokia's smartphone collapse, NASA's Challenger disaster, and Wells Fargo's account fraud scandal--illustrate the mechanism's operation across industries and failure modes. I derive five testable propositions and evaluate potential countermeasures through a mechanism design lens. The analysis reframes organizational dysfunction from moral failure to physics problem, explaining why standard interventions (culture change, leadership development, values alignment) so often fail: they treat equilibrium outcomes as behavioral problems rather than altering the selection environment that produces them.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑