基于机制的公平且维持 merit 的大学录取框架
A Mechanism-Based Planning Framework for Equitable and Merit-Preserving University Admissions
AI总结:
本文提出了一种基于机制的录取框架,通过调整 SES 分数来公平录取高 merit 个体,同时保持常规录取的稳定性。
摘要:
许多国家的录取系统难以在基于 merit 的选择与公平目标之间取得平衡。现有的大多数方法——类别配额、碎片化的公平路径和不透明的调整——缺乏透明的决策规则和操作一致性。本文介绍了适应性 merit 框架(AMF),一种基于机制的架构,结合了个体层面的 SES 调整规则和结构化决策流程。AMF 在非位移约束下运行:常规录取完全由原始 merit 分数决定,只有那些经过调整后表现超过相同阈值的申请人才有资格成为条件录取。该框架通过五个阶段的决策脊柱进行操作——输入定义、指标聚合、通过单个参数 alpha 进行公平校准、批量执行和不可逆关闭,从而消除机构的自由裁量权。使用 PISA 2022 韩国数据(N = 6,377)的实证应用表明,AMF 从 SES 分布的底部一半中识别出 4-9 个额外的候选人,所有人均超过 merit 阈值,使录取人数增加不到 cohort 的 0.15%。结果表明,基于规则的调整可以恢复被压制的高 merit 个体,而不影响标准录取,提供了一种透明且可扩展的替代方案,用于替代随意的公平干预。
英文摘要:
Admissions systems in many countries struggle to balance merit-based selection with equity objectives. Most existing approaches--categorical quotas, fragmented equity tracks, and opaque adjustments--lack transparent decision rules and operational coherence. This paper introduces the Adaptive Merit Framework (AMF), a mechanism-based architecture that combines an individual-level SES correction rule with a structured decision pipeline. AMF operates under a non-displacement constraint: regular admissions remain determined entirely by raw merit scores, and only applicants whose corrected performance exceeds the same threshold qualify as conditional admits. The framework is operationalized through a five-stage decision spine--input definition, indicator aggregation, equity calibration via a single parameter alpha, batch execution, and irreversible closure--eliminating institutional discretion throughout. An empirical application using PISA 2022 Korea data (N = 6,377) shows that AMF identifies 4-9 additional candidates exclusively from the bottom half of the SES distribution, all above the merit threshold, expanding admissions by fewer than 0.15% of the cohort. The results demonstrate that rule-based correction can recover suppressed high-merit individuals without displacing standard admits, providing a transparent and scalable alternative to discretionary equity interventions. Keywords: Mechanism design, Decision architecture, University admissions, Equity-efficiency tradeoff, Socioeconomic correction, Non-displacement
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。