arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2512.09352physics.soc-phcs.CYcs.SE
收藏

因果对称化作为复杂系统操作自主性的经验标志

Causal symmetrization as an empirical signature of operational autonomy in complex systems

Anthony Gosme

AI总结:

该研究通过实证分析揭示了复杂系统中因果对称化作为操作自主性的经验标志,结合结构持续性与活动耦合比,提出了新的动态评估方法。

摘要:

理论生物学长期以来提出,自主系统通过结构与活动之间的相互约束维持其身份,这种动态状态构成了诸如对高效因果的闭合性和自指的理论概念。尽管这些原则有影响,但它们在生物系统之外直接经验评估一直受到阻碍。在这里,我们通过识别与操作自主性一致的统计特征,对人工社会技术系统中的这一框架进行了实证评估。分析了50个大型协作软件生态系统,涵盖11,042个系统月,我们开发了一个序参量(Γ)来量化在组件更替下的结构持续性,并利用格兰杰因果性来表征组织架构与集体活动之间的方向耦合。Γ表现出双峰分布(Hartigan's dip检验p=0.0126;ΔBIC=2000),揭示了从高方差的探索状态到以1.77倍方差崩溃为特征的成熟状态之间的明显相变。在成熟状态下,因果对称化出现,结构-活动耦合比从0.71(活动驱动)变为0.94(双向)。一个结合活动和结构持续性的综合生存指数优于单独基于活动的预测(AUC=0.88 vs. 0.81),识别出“结构僵尸”系统,其中持续活动掩盖了架构退化。这些结果表明,因果对称化作为与理论闭合概念一致的必要统计特征发挥作用,而不意味着生物生命或机械闭合。它们表明,自主性核心原则可以在人工协作系统中进行实证探测,支持了复杂适应系统中自组织自主性的子系统无关动态特征。

英文摘要:

Theoretical biology has long proposed that autonomous systems sustain their identity through reciprocal constraints between structure and activity, a dynamical regime underlying concepts such as closure to efficient causation and autopoiesis. Despite their influence, these principles have resisted direct empirical assessment outside biological systems. Here, we empirically assess this framework in artificial sociotechnical systems by identifying a statistical signature consistent with operational autonomy. Analyzing 50 large-scale collaborative software ecosystems spanning 11,042 system-months, we develop an order parameter ($Γ$) quantifying structural persistence under component turnover and use Granger causality to characterize directional coupling between organizational architecture and collective activity. $Γ$ exhibits a bimodal distribution (Hartigan's dip test $p = 0.0126$; $Δ$BIC = 2000), revealing a sharp phase transition between an exploratory regime of high variance and a mature regime characterized by a 1.77-fold variance collapse. At maturity, causal symmetrization emerges, with the structure--activity coupling ratio shifting from 0.71 (activity-driven) to 0.94 (bidirectional). A composite viability index combining activity and structural persistence outperforms activity-based prediction alone (AUC = 0.88 vs. 0.81), identifying ``structural zombie'' systems in which sustained activity masks architectural decay. Together, these results show that causal symmetrization functions as a necessary statistical signature consistent with theoretical notions of operational closure, without implying biological life or mechanistic closure. They demonstrate that core principles of autonomy can be empirically probed in artificial collaborative systems, supporting substrate-independent dynamical signatures of self-organizing autonomy across complex adaptive systems.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑