arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2512.07099econ.EM
收藏

有限样本中随机化检验的局限性

Limitations of Randomization Tests in Finite Samples

University of Chicago(芝加哥大学);Columbia University(哥伦比亚大学)

Deniz Dutz, Xinyi Zhang

AI总结:

本文探讨了随机化检验在有限样本中的局限性,指出某些常见假设如零均值无法通过随机化检验实现精确检验,且仅限对称或高斯分布。

摘要:

随机化检验在有限样本中能够提供精确的I型错误控制,当原假设满足随机化假设时。然而,在实践中,实现这些保证往往需要比原假设本身更严格的条件。例如,检验零均值的符号检验要求对称性,并且不控制非对称零均值分布的有限样本大小。本文探讨了原假设与精确性所需不变条件之间的不匹配是否反映特定变换的使用,还是更根本的限制。我们为原假设是否允许随机化检验提供了一个简单的必要且充分条件。将此框架应用于单样本问题,我们characterize了允许在有限支持上进行随机化检验的原假设,并推导了在连续支持上的不可能结果。特别地,我们证明了几个常见的原假设,包括零均值,不允许随机化检验。此外,我们进一步表明,在使用线性群作用的一元检验中,允许的原假设仅限于对称或高斯分布的子集。这些结果证实了许多常见研究原假设的精确有限样本有效性缺失是固有的,并且使用现有检验的从业者并非在放弃可行的精确替代方案。

英文摘要:

Randomization tests deliver exact finite-sample Type 1 error control when the null satisfies the randomization hypothesis. In practice, achieving these guarantees often requires stronger conditions than the null hypothesis of primary interest. For example, sign-change tests of mean zero require symmetry and need not control finite-sample size for non-symmetric mean-zero distributions. We investigate whether the mismatch between the null and the invariance conditions required for exactness reflects the use of particular transformations or a more fundamental limitation. We provide a simple necessary and sufficient condition for a null hypothesis to admit a randomization test. Applying this framework to one-sample problems, we characterize the nulls that admit randomization tests on finite supports and derive impossibility results on continuous supports. In particular, we show that several common nulls, including mean zero, do not admit randomization tests. We further show that, among one-sample tests using linear group actions, the admissible nulls are limited to subsets of symmetric or Gaussian distributions. These results confirm that the absence of exact finite-sample validity is inherent for many commonly studied nulls and that practitioners using existing tests are not foregoing feasible exact alternatives.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑