AI监管准备指数ARRI:评估跨司法管辖区AI在电信中的法律准备性
The AI Regulatory Readiness Index ARRI: Assessing Cross-Jurisdictional Legal Preparedness for AI in Telecommunications
AI总结:
本文提出ARRI指数,用于评估各国法律框架对关键数字基础设施中AI的治理准备性,发现全球电信AI监管准备度较低,提出规范最低标准框架。
摘要:
随着人工智能日益嵌入关键电信基础设施,现有法律框架难以应对由此引入的独特风险。本文提出AI监管准备指数(ARRI),是一种可重复使用的工具,用于从 doctrinally 评估国家框架治理关键数字基础设施中AI的法律准备性,并应用于十个跨五个大洲的司法管辖区。ARRI包含三个维度的七个指标:特定AI义务、操作保障和治理协调,按四点顺序量表评分并汇总为标准化0-100指数。截至2026年2月28日生效的法律工具在电信、网络安全、数据保护和AI治理领域进行评估。研究发现,全球电信AI监管准备度集中在较低范围,平均ARRI得分为34,中位数为26.5。AI事件报告和风险分类成为最突出且几乎普遍的差距,各司法管辖区适用的法律框架中缺乏对AI特定事件的强制性法律定义。ARRI得分与现有综合指数系统存在系统性差异。例如,印度尼西亚获得ITU全球网络安全指数一级地位,但在ARRI中得分为19,表明网络安全准备性和AI监管准备性是法律上不同的条件,现有框架将其混淆。十个司法管辖区被划分为五个监管范式,并提出规范最低标准框架,将基线AI治理准备性锚定在ARRI得分为67。ARRI设计为可应用于能源、医疗和交通基础设施等其他领域。
英文摘要:
As Artificial Intelligence becomes increasingly embedded in critical telecommunications infrastructure, existing legal frameworks remain ill-equipped to address the distinct risks this development introduces. This paper proposes the AI Regulatory Readiness Index (ARRI), a reproducible instrument for doctrinally assessing the legal preparedness of national frameworks to govern AI in critical digital infrastructure, and applies it across ten jurisdictions spanning five continents. ARRI comprises seven indicators across three dimensions: substantive AI-specific obligations, operational safeguards, and governance coordination, scored on a four-point ordinal scale and aggregated to a normalised 0-100 index. Legal instruments in force as of 28 February 2026 are assessed across telecommunications, cybersecurity, data protection, and AI governance domains. The study finds that global AI regulatory readiness in telecommunications remains concentrated in the lower range, with a mean ARRI score of 34 and a median of 26.5. AI incident reporting and risk classification emerge as the most acute and near-universal gaps, with binding legal definitions of AI-specific incidents largely absent across the legal frameworks applicable to telecommunications in the jurisdictions studied. ARRI scores diverge systematically from existing composite indices. For example, Indonesia achieves ITU Global Cybersecurity Index Tier 1 status yet scores 19 under ARRI, demonstrating that cybersecurity readiness and AI regulatory readiness are legally distinct conditions that existing frameworks conflate. The ten jurisdictions are classified into five regulatory archetypes, and a normative minimum standards framework is proposed, anchoring baseline AI governance readiness at an ARRI score of 67. ARRI is designed to be sector-portable and applicable beyond telecommunications to energy, healthcare, and transport infrastructure.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。