生成式AI在全球南方STEAM教育中的情境化评估:人类专家的视角
Human Experts' Evaluation of Generative AI for Contextualizing STEAM Education in the Global South
AI总结:
本研究评估生成式AI在全球南方STEAM教育中的情境化能力,发现CRLP提升课程文化相关性,但AI在表现文化多样性方面存在不足,需教师介入与文化优化。
摘要:
全球南方许多地区STEAM教育仍显得抽象且与学习者的社会文化现实联系薄弱。本研究探讨了人类专家如何评估生成式AI(GenAI)在这些环境中情境化STEAM教学的能力。采用以人类为中心和文化响应教学为基础的混合方法设计,四位STEAM教育专家审查了标准化的加纳NaCCA课程计划和由定制的文化响应课程规划器(CRLP)生成的GenAI课程。定量数据通过经过验证的25项文化响应教学评估量表收集,评估偏见意识、文化表现、情境相关性、语言响应性和教师自主性。定性反思提供了每节课教学和文化动态的额外见解。研究发现,GenAI,尤其是通过CRLP,改善了抽象标准与学习者生活经验之间的联系。教师自主性是最强的领域,而文化表现是最弱的。CRLP生成的课程被评定为更具文化根基和教学吸引力。然而,GenAI在表现加纳文化多样性方面挣扎,常常产生表面化的参考,尤其是在数学和计算领域。专家强调需要教师调解、社区输入和文化导向的AI输出优化。未来工作应涉及课堂试验、更广泛的专家参与以及使用原住民语料库的微调。
英文摘要:
STEAM education in many parts of the Global South remains abstract and weakly connected to learners sociocultural realities. This study examines how human experts evaluate the capacity of Generative AI (GenAI) to contextualize STEAM instruction in these settings. Using a convergent mixed-methods design grounded in human-centered and culturally responsive pedagogy, four STEAM education experts reviewed standardized Ghana NaCCA lesson plans and GenAI-generated lessons created with a customized Culturally Responsive Lesson Planner (CRLP). Quantitative data were collected with a validated 25-item Culturally Responsive Pedagogy Rubric assessing bias awareness, cultural representation, contextual relevance, linguistic responsiveness, and teacher agency. Qualitative reflections provided additional insight into the pedagogical and cultural dynamics of each lesson. Findings show that GenAI, especially through the CRLP, improved connections between abstract standards and learners lived experiences. Teacher Agency was the strongest domain, while Cultural Representation was the weakest. CRLP-generated lessons were rated as more culturally grounded and pedagogically engaging. However, GenAI struggled to represent Ghana's cultural diversity, often producing surface-level references, especially in Mathematics and Computing. Experts stressed the need for teacher mediation, community input, and culturally informed refinement of AI outputs. Future work should involve classroom trials, broader expert participation, and fine-tuning with Indigenous corpora.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。