生物医学文献中相关系数的错误报告与错误解释的普遍性
The Prevalence of Misreporting and Misinterpreting Correlation Coefficients in Biomedical Literature
AI总结:
针对生物医学文献中相关系数误用与误解释问题,研究通过回顾三大期刊310篇文章的相关分析记录,发现样本量和置信区间报告缺失、依赖点估计或零假设检验等普遍问题,倡导强制报告效应量和置信区间的指南以提升研究可信度。
摘要:
相关系数在生物医学和生物学文献中被广泛使用,但其频繁的误用和错误解释损害了科学发现的可信度和可重复性。我们系统回顾了2022年发表在《Science》《Nature》和《Nature Neuroscience》的310篇文章中1326项相关分析记录。分析揭示了统计报告和推断不良的令人担忧模式:58.71%(95% CI:[53.23%,64.19%],182/310)的研究未明确报告样本量,98.06%(95% CI:[96.53%,99.60%],304/310)未提供相关系数的置信区间。在177篇推断相关强度的文章中,45.25%(95% CI:[38.42%,53.10%],81/177)仅依赖点估计,53.63%(95% CI:[46.90%,61.58%],96/177)基于零假设显著性检验得出结论。这种普遍的遗漏和误用凸显了统计素养和编辑标准的系统性差距。我们倡导明确的报告指南,强制要求相关分析中报告效应量和置信区间,以提高定量生命科学研究的透明度、严谨性和可重复性。
英文摘要:
Correlation coefficient is widely used in biomedical and biological literature, yet its frequent misuse and misinterpretation undermine the credibility and reproducibility of the scientific findings. We systematically reviewed 1326 records of correlation analyses across 310 articles published in Science, Nature, and Nature Neuroscience in 2022. Our analysis revealed a troubling pattern of poor statistical reporting and inferring: 58.71% (95% CI: [53.23%, 64.19%], 182/310) of studies did not explicitly report sample sizes, and 98.06% (95% CI: [96.53%, 99.60%], 304/310) failed to provide confidence intervals for correlation coefficients. Among 177 articles inferring correlation strength, 45.25% (95% CI: [38.42%, 53.10%], 81/177) relied solely on point estimates, while 53.63% (95% CI: [46.90%, 61.58%], 96/177) drew conclusions based on null hypothesis significance testing. This widespread omission and misuse highlight a systematic gap in both statistic literacy and editorial standards. We advocate clear reporting guidelines mandating effect sizes and confidence intervals in correlation analyses to enhance the transparency, rigor, and reproducibility of quantitative life sciences research.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。