arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2511.08461cs.CYcs.CL
收藏

定性研究方法中的生成式人工智能:在炒作与风险之间?

Generative Artificial Intelligence in Qualitative Research Methods: Between Hype and Risks?

Human-IST Institute, University of Fribourg(弗里堡大学 Human-IST 研究所);Scip AG(Scip 股份公司)

Maria Couto Teixeira, Marisa Tschopp, Anna Jobin

AI总结:

本立场文件批判性审视生成式AI(genAI)在定性编码方法论中的作用,指出其因缺乏有效文档、商业不透明及易产生错误输出等问题不具备方法论有效性,风险大于收益,提醒研究者优先考虑可靠方法论而非技术新颖性。

摘要:

随着人工智能(AI)在定性研究中得到越来越多的推广和应用,它也引发了深刻的方法论问题。本立场文件批判性地审视了生成式AI(genAI)在定性编码方法论背景下的作用。尽管存在广泛的炒作和关于效率的宣称,但我们认为genAI在定性研究中不具备方法论有效性,其使用可能会破坏定性研究的稳健性和可信度。缺乏有意义的文档记录、商业不透明性以及genAI系统产生错误输出的固有倾向,均会导致方法论严谨性的削弱。总体而言,风险与收益的平衡不支持在定性研究中使用genAI,我们的立场文件提醒研究者应将可靠的方法论置于技术新颖性之前。

英文摘要:

As Artificial Intelligence (AI) is increasingly promoted and used in qualitative research, it also raises profound methodological issues. This position paper critically interrogates the role of generative AI (genAI) in the context of qualitative coding methodologies. Despite widespread hype and claims of efficiency, we propose that genAI is not methodologically valid within qualitative inquiries, and its use risks undermining the robustness and trustworthiness of qualitative research. The lack of meaningful documentation, commercial opacity, and the inherent tendencies of genAI systems to produce incorrect outputs all contribute to weakening methodological rigor. Overall, the balance between risk and benefits does not support the use of genAI in qualitative research, and our position paper cautions researchers to put sound methodology before technological novelty.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑