语义透明度对社会目标模型理解与评审的影响研究
On the impact of semantic transparency on understanding and reviewing social goal models
AI总结:
本文通过准实验研究语义透明度对 i* 目标模型理解与评审的影响,发现替代语法虽未提升准确性和速度,但显著降低了用户的视觉努力。
摘要:
背景:i* 是需求工程研究领域最具影响力的语言之一。可能由于其复杂性以及在工业界的低采用率,它自然成为旨在改进其具体语法以及利益相关者正确解读 i* 模型能力的研究对象。目标:我们评估在存在语言图例(language key)的情况下,语义透明度对理解和评审 i* 模型的影响。方法:我们进行了一项准实验,将标准 i* 具体语法与一种具有更高语义透明度的替代语法进行比较。我们要求 57 名新手参与者对 i* 模型执行理解和评审任务,并使用任务成功率、时间和努力程度等指标,结合眼动追踪和参与者反馈来测量他们的准确性、速度和易用性。结果:我们没有发现证据表明替代具体语法能提高准确性或速度。尽管参与者感知的易用性相似,但在使用替代具体语法时,他们对模型和所提供的语言图例投入的视觉努力显著减少。结论:模型和语言图例所提供的上下文可能缓解了先前工作中报告的 i* 符号识别缺陷。然而,替代具体语法所需的视觉努力显著更低。
英文摘要:
Context: i* is one of the most influential languages in the Requirements Engineering research community. Perhaps due to its complexity and low adoption in industry, it became a natural candidate for studies aiming at improving its concrete syntax and the stakeholders' ability to correctly interpret i* models. Objectives: We evaluate the impact of semantic transparency on understanding and reviewing i* models, in the presence of a language key. Methods: We performed a quasi-experiment comparing the standard i* concrete syntax with an alternative that has an increased semantic transparency. We asked 57 novice participants to perform understanding and reviewing tasks on i* models, and measured their accuracy, speed and ease, using metrics of task success, time and effort, collected with eye-tracking and participants' feedback. Results: We found no evidence of improved accuracy or speed attributable to the alternative concrete syntax. Although participants' perceived ease was similar, they devoted significantly less visual effort to the model and the provided language key, when using the alternative concrete syntax. Conclusions: The context provided by the model and language key may mitigate the i* symbol recognition deficit reported in previous works. However, the alternative concrete syntax required a significantly lower visual effort.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。