从层间因果关系的角度考虑意识的生成机制
Avoiding Epiphenomenalism in Theories of Consciousness: A Causal Framework Based on Asymmetry
AI总结:
本文从层间因果关系出发,提出意识的生成由系统内部因果机制决定,而非功能,并通过双定律模型解释意识生成及其因果性。
摘要:
为什么有些物理系统拥有意识,而其他系统却没有?我们不将意识视为主观体验,而是将其视为伴随体验的物理事件。这是一个物理学问题吗?还是因果关系理论的问题?物理学和因果关系理论服务于不同的描述目的。为了描述因果模型,我们引入了因果之间的不对称关系,这对于描述因果关系是必要的,但对于物理定律则不是。我们提出意识的生成由系统的内部因果机制决定,而不是由系统的功能(即物理决定的输入-输出关系)决定。为了解释这些内在原因,我们关注整体到部分的因果关系。传统上,整体到部分的因果关系被视为涌现现象而非机制。我们设计了一种方法,通过检查源自较高层次的原因如何在系统内传递到较低层次,来在因果模型中显式实现这些机制。然后,我们提出了一个双定律模型(DLM),该模型在较高和较低层次具有不同的动力学定律。最后,我们基于DLM讨论了功能性意识的生成及其因果关系。
英文摘要:
Why do some physical systems possess consciousness, while others do not? A scientific theory of consciousness must explain differences in system behavior in terms of well-defined internal mechanisms. However, many existing approaches introduce higher-level structural or informational descriptions without specifying how these structures contribute to the generation of behavior, raising the concern that they may become theoretically ineffective.A further difficulty arises from the status of causation. Attempts to introduce causally effective mental states appear to conflict with physical theory, while strictly physicalist accounts risk excluding higher-level causation altogether. We argue that this dilemma stems from a conflation of physical determination with causation. To address this issue, we distinguish between two complementary descriptive frameworks: the physical stance and the causal stance. While the physical stance represents systems in terms of state evolution, the causal stance introduces asymmetric relations that enable the explicit representation of internal mechanisms. We show that causal descriptions provide a more constrained and informative representation of internal structure and cannot, in general, be reconstructed from physical descriptions alone. Within this framework, we define mental causation in terms of intrinsic causes and propose the Dual-Laws Model (DLM), which explicitly implements whole-to-parts causal mechanisms. This approach provides a principled way to model the causal role of consciousness without violating physical determinism.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。