改造者、实用主义者和活动家:为可问责的自动化决策而进行的公益诉讼
Retrofitters, pragmatists and activists: Public interest litigation for accountable automated decision-making
AI总结:
本文探讨公益诉讼在澳大利亚促进AI和自动化决策问责中的作用,基于访谈分析策略与局限,强调制度安排对有效诉讼的关键性。
摘要:
本文考察了公益诉讼在促进澳大利亚人工智能和自动化决策(ADM)问责方面的作用。由于ADM监管面临政治和地缘政治阻力,有效的治理将不得不依赖现有法律的执行。基于对澳大利亚公益诉讼律师、技术政策活动家和技术法学学者的访谈,本文将公益诉讼定位为ADM透明度、问责和正义的更大生态系统的一部分。文章探讨了参与者所称的“改造”旧法律以适应ADM的策略和战术。这些策略超越了创造性的法律论证,涵盖了社区建设、变革理论合作、精明的客户和诉讼理由选择,以及诉讼中利益相关者利益的协调。自然,本文也探讨了这些策略以及澳大利亚法律体系的局限性。然而,在局限可以被克服的地方,本文提出了关于紧迫需求的发现:使有效诉讼和问责得以实现的制度安排。本文对法律和技术学者、受ADM伤害的个人和团体、公益诉讼律师和技术律师、民间社会和倡导组织以及政策制定者具有参考价值。
英文摘要:
This paper examines the role of public interest litigation in promoting accountability for AI and automated decision-making (ADM) in Australia. Since ADM regulation faces political and geopolitical headwinds, effective governance will have to rely on the enforcement of existing laws. Drawing on interviews with Australian public interest litigators, technology policy activists, and technology law scholars, the paper positions public interest litigation as part of a larger ecosystem for transparency, accountability and justice with respect to ADM. The paper explores the tactics and strategies of what one participant described as 'retrofitting' old laws to ADM. These go beyond creative legal argumentation, to encompass practices of community-building, collaboration on theories of change, canny selection of clients and causes of action, and aligning the interests of stakeholders in litigation. Naturally, the paper also contends with the limits of these strategies, and of the Australian legal system. Where limits are capable of being overcome, the paper presents findings on urgent needs: the enabling institutional arrangements without which effective litigation and accountability will falter. The paper is relevant to law and technology scholars, individuals and groups harmed by ADM, public interest litigators and technology lawyers, civil society and advocacy organisations, and policymakers.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。