arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2510.26727econ.GNcs.CYq-fin.EC
收藏

既非同意亦非财产:数据法的政策实验室

Neither Consent nor Property: A Policy Lab for Data Law

Law School, Peking University(北京大学法学院)

Haoyi Zhang, Tianyi Zhu

AI总结:

本文通过构建数据市场的Agent-Based模型,探讨数据法中同意与财产规则对福利的影响,发现将实质性损害责任转移给下游买家可最大化社会福利。

摘要:

监管者目前在AI数据经济中基于直觉而非证据进行治理,难以在知情同意、免责与责任之间做出选择。本文开发了一种新的计算政策实验室:一个空间显式的数据市场Agent-Based模型。为解决数据缺失问题,我们引入了两阶段方法论流程。首先,我们将多年的实地调研(2022-2025)中的决策规则转化为代理约束,确保模型反映实际的谈判摩擦而非理论抽象。其次,我们部署大型语言模型(LLMs)作为离散选择实验(DCE)中的“受试者”。这种新方法恢复了精确的偏好原始数据,如支付意愿弹性,这些在现实中无法观测到。通过这些输入校准,我们的模型将竞争性的法律机构并置,以模拟其福利效应。结果挑战了主导的监管范式。我们发现,财产规则机制,如知情同意,未能最大化福利。反直觉的是,社会福利在将实质性损害责任转移给下游买家时达到峰值。这与“最低成本避免者”原则一致,因为下游用户控制采购后的保障措施,他们最能有效缓解风险。通过“去浪漫化”卖方中心框架,本文为新兴的下游可及性法理提供了经济依据。

英文摘要:

Regulators currently govern the AI data economy based on intuition rather than evidence, struggling to choose between inconsistent regimes of informed consent, immunity, and liability. To fill this policy vacuum, this paper develops a novel computational policy laboratory: a spatially explicit Agent-Based Model (ABM) of the data market. To solve the problem of missing data, we introduce a two-stage methodological pipeline. First, we translate decision rules from multi-year fieldwork (2022-2025) into agent constraints. This ensures the model reflects actual bargaining frictions rather than theoretical abstractions. Second, we deploy Large Language Models (LLMs) as "subjects" in a Discrete Choice Experiment (DCE). This novel approach recovers precise preference primitives, such as willingness-to-pay elasticities, which are empirically unobservable in the wild. Calibrated by these inputs, our model places rival legal institutions side-by-side to simulate their welfare effects. The results challenge the dominant regulatory paradigm. We find that property-rule mechanisms, such as informed consent, fail to maximize welfare. Counterintuitively, social welfare peaks when liability for substantive harm is shifted to the downstream buyer. This aligns with the "least cost avoider" principle, because downstream users control post-acquisition safeguards, they are best positioned to mitigate risk efficiently. By "de-romanticizing" seller-centric frameworks, this paper provides an economic justification for emerging doctrines of downstream reachability.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑