arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2510.26490cs.HC
收藏

搭建创造力支架:发散型与聚合型LLM角色如何塑造人机创造性问题解决

Scaffolding Creativity: How Divergent and Convergent LLM Personas Shape Human Machine Creative Problem-Solving

Ben-Gurion University of the Negev(内盖夫本-古里安大学);Shenkar - College of Engineering. Design. Art(申肯工程设计与艺术学院)

Alon Rosenbaum, Yigal David, Eran Kaufman, Gilad Ravid, Amit Ronen, Assaf Krebs

AI总结:

本研究针对LLM可能削弱人类创造力的问题,开发了具备发散与聚合思维角色的教练式LLM环境,通过实验发现用户感知与客观绩效存在偏差、个体差异可预测角色使用偏好,为人机协作的创造力支持系统提供了设计原则。

摘要:

大语言模型(LLM)正日益影响创意工作与问题解决,但此前研究表明它们可能削弱无辅助状态下的创造力。为化解这一矛盾,本研究开发了类似教练的LLM环境,将发散思维与聚合思维角色作为两个互补过程加以实现。研究通过对照实验评估了效果与用户行为:参与者分别与两种角色互动,对照组则使用直接给出答案的标准LLM。值得注意的是,用户对于哪种角色最能支撑自身创造力的感知,往往与客观绩效指标存在偏差。基于特质的分析显示,个体差异可预测人们何时使用发散型或聚合型角色,这为自适应排序提供了可能。此外,互动模式符合设计思维模型,展现了角色引导的支持如何塑造创造性问题解决过程。本研究结果为创造力支持系统提供了设计原则,即通过基于角色的引导与个性化,在探索与聚合之间取得平衡。这些见解推动了人机协作工具的发展,使其能够为人类创造力搭建支架而非掩盖其光芒。

英文摘要:

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly shaping creative work and problem-solving; however, prior research suggests that they may diminish unassisted creativity. To address this tension, a coach-like LLM environment was developed that embodies divergent and convergent thinking personas as two complementary processes. Effectiveness and user behavior were assessed through a controlled experiment in which participants interacted with either persona, while a control group engaged with a standard LLM providing direct answers. Notably, users' perceptions of which persona best supported their creativity often diverged from objective performance measures. Trait-based analyses revealed that individual differences predict when people utilize divergent versus convergent personas, suggesting opportunities for adaptive sequencing. Furthermore, interaction patterns reflected the design thinking model, demonstrating how persona-guided support shapes creative problem-solving. Our findings provide design principles for creativity support systems that strike a balance between exploration and convergence through persona-based guidance and personalization. These insights advance human-AI collaboration tools that scaffold rather than overshadow human creativity.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑