Large language models (LLMs) increasingly rely on thinking models that externalize intermediate steps and allocate extra test-time compute, with think-twice strategies showing that a deliberate second pass can elicit stronger reasoning. In contrast, most reward models (RMs) still compress many quality dimensions into a single scalar in one shot, a design that induces judgment diffusion: attention spreads across evaluation criteria, yielding diluted focus and shallow analysis. We introduce branch-and-rethink (BR-RM), a two-turn RM that transfers the think-twice principle to reward modeling. Turn 1 performs adaptive branching, selecting a small set of instance-critical dimensions (such as factuality and safety) and sketching concise, evidence-seeking hypotheses. Turn 2 executes branch-conditioned rethinking, a targeted reread that tests those hypotheses and scrutinizes only what matters most. We train with GRPO-style reinforcement learning over structured two-turn traces using a simple binary outcome reward with strict format checks, making the approach compatible with standard RLHF pipelines. By converting all-at-once scoring into focused, second-look reasoning, BR-RM reduces judgment diffusion and improves sensitivity to subtle yet consequential errors while remaining practical and scalable. Experimental results demonstrate that our model achieves state-of-the-art performance on three challenging reward modeling benchmarks across diverse domains.
Rethinking External Slow-Thinking: From Snowball Errors to Probability of Correct Reasoning
Gaoling School of Artificial Intelligence, Renmin University of China, Beijing, China(中国人民大学人工智能学院);Beijing Key Laboratory of Research on Large Models(北京大型模型研究关键实验室);Engineering Research Center of Next-Generation Intelligent Search(下一代智能搜索工程研究中心);College of Artificial Intelligence, Tianjin University of Science(天津科技大学人工智能学院)
Rethinking the Chain-of-Thought: The Roles of In-Context Learning and Pre-trained Priors
School of Intelligence Science and Technology, National Key Laboratory for Novel Software Technology, Nanjing University(智能科学与技术学院,新型软件技术国家重点实验室,南京大学);School of Computing and Information Systems, Singapore Management University(计算与信息系统学院,新加坡管理大学);Central South University(中南大学);School of Global Education and Development, International Chinese Language Education, University of Chinese Academy of Social Sciences(全球教育与发展学院,国际中文教育,中国社会科学院)