arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2510.22933cs.CY
收藏

人工智能如何增强获得正义的途径?公共辩护人对人工智能采用的看法

How Can AI Augment Access to Justice? Public Defenders' Perspectives on AI Adoption

Princeton University(普林斯顿大学)

Inyoung Cheong, Patty Liu, Dominik Stammbach, Peter Henderson

AI总结:

本文通过访谈17名美国公共辩护人,探讨人工智能在公共辩护工作中的应用潜力与伦理限制,提出五项核心任务框架,并强调需通过开放科学和领域数据集促进公平正义。

摘要:

公共辩护人面临资源匮乏和案卷压力,人工智能被宣传为减轻行政和认知负担的手段,但法律AI研究鲜少关注公共辩护的实际需求。本文基于对17名公共辩护人进行的深入半结构化访谈,识别出最适合人工智能协助的任务,包括证据调查、法律研究与写作、客户沟通与支持、法庭辩护及辩护策略。受访者普遍认为证据调查(如审查大量数字记录)是AI最具潜力的领域,而法律研究和客户沟通的AI应用有限,法庭辩护和策略则最不兼容。AI的采用受成本、办公室规范、保密风险和工具质量限制。本文强调需通过强制性的人类验证、限制过度依赖和保护律师关系等方面建立责任使用保障,并提出以开放科学、构建领域特定数据集和纳入一线实践者视角为核心的研究议程,以促进公平正义的获取。

英文摘要:

Public defenders are asked to do more with less: representing clients deserving of adequate counsel while facing overwhelming caseloads and scarce resources. Although artificial intelligence (AI) is often promoted as a means of relieving administrative and cognitive burdens, legal AI research rarely engages with the everyday realities of public defense work. Drawing on in-depth, semi-structured interviews with 17 public defense professionals across the United States, we identify work-intensive tasks most amenable to AI assistance and the ethical constraints involved in legal representation. We develop a comprehensive task-level map of public defense work, dividing it into five pillars to clarify where AI can and cannot contribute: evidence investigation, legal research & writing, client communication & support, courtroom representation, and defense strategies. Interviewees consistently identified evidence investigation, such as reviewing large volumes of digital records, as the area with the greatest potential for AI support. AI was viewed as having more limited roles in legal research and client communication, and as least compatible with courtroom representation and defense strategy. We find that AI adoption is constrained by costs, restrictive office norms, confidentiality risks, and unsatisfactory tool quality. Our interviewees emphasize safeguards for responsible use, including mandatory human verification, limits on over-reliance, and the preservation of relational aspects of lawyering. Building on these findings, we outline a research agenda that promotes equitable access to justice by prioritizing open science, building domain-specific datasets and evaluation, and incorporating frontline practitioners' perspectives into system development.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑