arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2510.19261cs.AI
收藏

ChatGPT 揭示其局限:法律原则带来将死之局

ChatGPT Unveils Its Limits: Principles of Law Deliver Checkmate

University of Turin - Computer Science Dept., Italy(意大利都灵大学计算机科学系);School of Engineering and Technology, Central Queensland University, Australia(澳大利亚中央昆士兰大学工程与技术学院)

Marianna Molinari, Ilaria Angela Amantea, Marinella Quaranta, Guido Governatori

AI总结:

本研究通过法律实验发现,ChatGPT 虽具备知识但无法整合推理以产出详尽结果,揭示其在需要全面理解与推理的复杂任务中的固有局限,表明真正智能仍为人类独有。

摘要:

本研究通过法律领域的实验考察了 ChatGPT 的性能。我们将其结果与使用正则表达式(Regex)的基线进行了比较,而非仅专注于与人类表现的评估。研究表明,即使 ChatGPT 拥有必要的知识和能力,它也无法将它们整合起来,以推理出详尽的结果。这揭示了 ChatGPT 的一个重大局限。智能包含将复杂问题分解并根据多种所需能力加以处理、提供统一且全面解决方案的能力。在法律领域,最关键的任務之一是阅读法律判决并提取浓缩自法律原则(PoLs)的关键段落,这些段落随后被法官纳入后续裁决或律师用于辩护文件。在执行此任务时,人工智能缺乏全面的理解和推理能力,这使其本质上受到限制。真正的智能仍然是人类独有的特质,至少在这一特定领域是如此。

英文摘要:

This study examines the performance of ChatGPT with an experiment in the legal domain. We compare the outcome with it a baseline using regular expressions (Regex), rather than focusing solely on the assessment against human performance. The study reveals that even if ChatGPT has access to the necessary knowledge and competencies, it is unable to assemble them, reason through, in a way that leads to an exhaustive result. This unveils a major limitation of ChatGPT. Intelligence encompasses the ability to break down complex issues and address them according to multiple required competencies, providing a unified and comprehensive solution. In the legal domain, one of the most crucial tasks is reading legal decisions and extracting key passages condensed from principles of law (PoLs), which are then incorporated into subsequent rulings by judges or defense documents by lawyers. In performing this task, artificial intelligence lacks an all-encompassing understanding and reasoning, which makes it inherently limited. Genuine intelligence, remains a uniquely human trait, at least in this particular field.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑