高 vs. 低 AGI:面向地缘政治一致性的本体论与概念分类法
High vs. Low AGI: Ontology and Conceptual Taxonomy for Geopolitical Coherence
AI总结:
本文提出一种区分低AGI与高AGI的本体论分类法,结合高/低政治与解释水平理论,以细化风险评估和治理设计,应对AGI的地缘政治挑战。
摘要:
通用人工智能(AGI)研究的快速发展,要求我们具备能够区分面向开放商业集成开发的系统与面向主权安全化部署的系统的概念工具。若无此类区分,风险评估与监管辩论会将AGI归入不适用的传统双重用途框架,此类框架虽能捕捉民用与军用应用的可能性,却忽视了企业级与国家级架构所产生的不同社会谱系。本文提出一种区分低AGI与高AGI的分类法,阐明商业-经济架构与安全-主权架构不仅可在功能上区分,还可依据产生它们的社会与政治生态系统加以区分。该分类法借鉴了国际关系中“高/低政治”的概念,并通过解释水平理论加以审视,从而能够捕捉在AGI新兴地缘政治利害关系中合作与冲突可能并存的情形。通过将AGI嵌入权力结构与安全化理论,本贡献通过一种本体论分类法扩展了双重用途话语,该分类法能够实现更细粒度的风险评估与治理设计——使政策制定者和研究人员能够预见国际体系中的安全困境、制度需求以及技术-政治溢出效应。
英文摘要:
The rapid progression of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) research demands conceptual tools capable of distinguishing between systems developed for open, commercial integration and those destined for sovereign, securitized deployments. Without such distinctions, risk assessments and regulatory debates collapse AGI into legacy dual-use frameworks that are ill-suited for these resources, capturing the possibility of civilian and military application but overlooking the distinct societal lineages yielded by corporate and state-grade architectures. This paper proposes a taxonomy distinguishing low-AGI and high-AGI, clarifying how commercial-economic and security-sovereign architectures can be distinguished not only by function, but by the social and political ecosystems that produce them. The taxonomy builds on international relations concepts of "high/low politics," viewed through the lens of construal-level theory, which allows it to even capture how cooperation and conflict may coexist in the context of AGI's emerging geopolitical stakes. By embedding AGI within power structures and securitization theory, this contribution extends dual-use discourse through an ontological taxonomy that enables more granular risk assessment and governance design--equipping policymakers and researchers to anticipate security dilemmas, institutional demands, and technical-political spillovers in the international system.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。