Komitee Equal Shares:通过协同设计的虚拟预算算法以选民和群体身份共同决策
Komitee Equal Shares: Choosing Together as Voters and as Groups with a Co-designed Virtual Budget Algorithm
AI总结:
本研究提出Komitee Equal Shares可定价虚拟预算分配框架,整合选民投票与群体评估两类信号并扩展等份额方法,经瑞士温特图尔文化委员会部署验证,填补社会选择领域决策模式单一的空白,实现可解释的比例分配。
摘要:
公共资助流程需要公平性、可学习性以及参与者能够理解的结果。我们提出Komitee Equal Shares,这是一种可定价的虚拟预算分配框架,整合两类信号:在选民模式下,参与者投出点数票;在评估者模式下,小型群体依据集体定义的影响领域评估提案。该框架扩展了等份额方法(Method of Equal Shares),将两类信号转化为虚拟购买力并生成投票凭证。我们在瑞士温特图尔2025年文化委员会(Kultur Komitee)中部署了该框架。我们的贡献包括:(1)明确区分决策模式,填补了社会选择领域的一项空白——该领域通常将参与式预算视为偏好聚合,而公民同时也将自身视为评估者;(2)设计投票凭证,将可定价性转化为面向参与者的解释,使比例分配清晰可追溯。该框架可推广至参与式资助发放和预算编制,提供一种让公民在同一比例化、可解释的分配机制中同时担任选民和评估者的模式。
英文摘要:
Public funding processes demand fairness, learning, and outcomes that participants can understand. We introduce Komitee Equal Shares, a priceable virtual-budget allocation framework that integrates two signals: in voter mode, participants cast point votes; in evaluator mode, small groups assess proposals against collectively defined impact fields. The framework extends the Method of Equal Shares by translating both signals into virtual spending power and producing voting receipts. We deployed the framework in the 2025 Kultur Komitee in Winterthur, Switzerland. Our contributions are: (1) a clear separation of decision modes, addressing a gap in social choice that typically treats participatory budgeting as preference aggregation while citizens also see themselves as evaluators; and (2) the design of voting receipts that operationalise priceability into participant-facing explanations, making proportional allocations legible and traceable. The framework generalises to participatory grant-making and budgeting, offering a model where citizens act as voters and evaluators within one proportional, explainable allocation.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。