arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2510.01124physics.ed-ph
收藏

超越命名方法:基于课堂观察网络的主动学习类型学

Beyond named methods: A typology of active learning based on classroom observation networks

Drexel University(德雷塞尔大学);Michigan State University(密歇根州立大学);Bryn Mawr College(布林莫尔学院);University of Copenhagen(哥本哈根大学)

Meagan Sundstrom, Justin Gambrell, Colin Green, Adrienne L. Traxler, Eric Brewe

AI总结:

通过课堂观察网络分析,定义了五种主动学习教学类型,发现命名方法与实际教学类型无显著关联,且学生概念学习在不同类型间无差异。

摘要:

越来越多的物理入门课程教师正在课堂中实施主动学习方法,并根据本地教学环境进行调整。然而,我们缺乏一个详细的框架来描述教师对主动学习方法的调整在实践中呈现的范围。现有研究对课堂观察应用结构化协议并报告描述性统计,但这种方法忽视了教学的复杂性。在本研究中,我们将网络分析应用于课堂观察,以定义一种考虑教学实践的时间性和互动性的主动学习类型学。我们使用了来自27所机构30名教师的视频数据,这些教师在他们的物理或天文学入门课程中实施了以下命名主动学习方法之一:探究性科学学习环境(ISLE)、同伴教学、辅导课以及以学生为中心的主动学习环境与倒置教学法(SCALE-UP)。我们识别出五种主动学习教学类型:点击器讲座、对话式点击器讲座、带有短小组活动的对话式讲座、短小组活动和长小组活动。我们发现这些教学类型与命名主动学习方法之间没有显著关系;相反,四种方法中的每一种的实施都分布在不同的教学类型中。这一结果促使我们改变对主动学习的思考和谈论方式:已开发的主动学习方法的名称可能实际上并不反映教学过程中发生的具体活动。我们还发现,学生的概念学习在所识别的教学类型之间没有差异,这表明教师在调整这些方法时可能具有灵活性,而不会牺牲有效性。

英文摘要:

A growing number of introductory physics instructors are implementing active learning methods in their classrooms, and they are modifying the methods to fit their local instructional contexts. However, we lack a detailed framework for describing the range of what these instructor adaptations of active learning methods look like in practice. Existing studies apply structured protocols to classroom observations and report descriptive statistics, but this approach overlooks the complex nature of instruction. In this study, we apply network analysis to classroom observations to define a typology of active learning that considers the temporal and interactional nature of instructional practices. We use video data from 30 instructors at 27 institutions who implemented one of the following named active learning methods in their introductory physics or astronomy course: Investigative Science Learning Environment (ISLE), Peer Instruction, Tutorials, and Student-Centered Active Learning Environment with Upside-down Pedagogies (SCALE-UP). We identify five types of active learning instruction: clicker lecture, dialogic clicker lecture, dialogic lecture with short groupwork activities, short groupwork activities, and long groupwork activities. We find no significant relationship between these instruction types and the named active learning methods; instead, implementations of each of the four methods are spread across different instruction types. This result prompts a shift in the way we think and talk about active learning: the names of developed active learning methods may not actually reflect the specific activities that happen during instruction. We also find that student conceptual learning does not vary across the identified instruction types, suggesting that instructors may be flexible when modifying these methods without sacrificing effectiveness.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑