谁为RENT买单?空间不平等对基于预测的分配政策的影响
Who Pays the RENT? Implications of Spatial Inequality for Prediction-Based Allocation Policies
AI总结:
本文通过Mallows模型和RENT指标研究空间不平等如何影响个人定向与社区定向资源分配政策的相对效果,并利用美国城市驱逐数据校准模型,发现个人定向在高度隔离地区仍能显著提升高风险家庭覆盖数量,从而调和了既有研究中的矛盾结论。
摘要:
由人工智能驱动的稀缺资源分配政策依赖预测来针对特定个人(例如高风险个人)或特定环境(例如社区)。近期关于个人层面定向的研究显示出相互矛盾的结果;一些模型表明,当不平等程度较高时,定向并不有效,而其他研究则展示了潜在收益。为研究并调和这一明显分歧,我们基于Mallows模型开发了一个简化框架,以理解不平等的空间分布如何影响逐户外展政策的有效性。我们引入了RENT(非定向相对效率)指标,用以在高风险家庭空间集中程度较高与较低的情况下,评估定向方法相较于基于社区的方法在防止租户被驱逐方面的有效性。随后,我们利用美国一座中等城市收集的驱逐法院记录对模型参数进行校准。结果表明,即使在驱逐风险高度集中且居住隔离严重的都市区,通过个人定向政策走访到的高风险家庭数量也获得了显著提升。我们得出结论,先前文献中的明显分歧可以通过考虑以下两点得到调和:1)部署成本的来源,以及2)观察到的风险集中度与建模得到的风险集中度之间的差异。我们的结果为在特定应用场景和地理条件下部署基于人工智能的社会服务供给方案提供了参考。
英文摘要:
AI-powered scarce resource allocation policies rely on predictions to target either specific individuals (e.g., high-risk) or settings (e.g., neighborhoods). Recent research on individual-level targeting demonstrates conflicting results; some models show that targeting is not useful when inequality is high, while other work demonstrates potential benefits. To study and reconcile this apparent discrepancy, we develop a stylized framework based on the Mallows model to understand how the spatial distribution of inequality affects the effectiveness of door-to-door outreach policies. We introduce the RENT (Relative Efficiency of Non-Targeting) metric, which we use to assess the effectiveness of targeting approaches compared with neighborhood-based approaches in preventing tenant eviction when high-risk households are more versus less spatially concentrated. We then calibrate the model parameters to eviction court records collected in a medium-sized city in the USA. Results demonstrate considerable gains in the number of high-risk households canvassed through individually targeted policies, even in a highly segregated metro area with concentrated risks of eviction. We conclude that apparent discrepancies in the prior literature can be reconciled by considering 1) the source of deployment costs and 2) the observed versus modeled concentrations of risk. Our results inform the deployment of AI-based solutions in social service provision that account for particular applications and geographies.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。