arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2507.08038cs.CLcs.AI
收藏

AblationBench:评估实证AI研究中消融实验的自动规划

AblationBench: Evaluating Automated Planning of Ablations in Empirical AI Research

Google Research(谷歌研究)

Talor Abramovich, Gal Chechik

AI总结:

提出AblationBench基准套件,包含作者消融和审稿人消融两个任务,用于评估语言模型在AI研究中规划消融实验的能力,实验表明当前最佳模型仅能识别45%的原始消融,低于人类水平。

摘要:

语言模型代理越来越多地被用于自动化科学研究,然而评估其科学贡献仍然是一个挑战。获得此类见解的关键机制是通过消融实验。为此,我们引入了AblationBench,这是一个用于评估代理在实证AI研究中进行消融规划任务的基准套件。它包括两个任务:AuthorAblation,帮助作者基于方法部分提出消融实验,包含83个实例;以及ReviewerAblation,帮助审稿人发现完整论文中缺失的消融,包含350个实例。对于这两个任务,我们开发了基于LM的评判器,作为自动评估框架。我们对前沿LM的实验表明,这些任务仍然具有挑战性,性能最佳的LM系统平均仅能识别45%的原始消融,低于人类水平。我们观察到作者任务和审稿人任务之间存在相反的性能趋势,这归因于模型基础的不同。最后,我们分析了当前LM在这些任务上的局限性,并发现思维链提示优于基于代理的方法。我们的数据可在https://huggingface.co/collections/ai-coscientist/ablationbench获取,代码可在https://github.com/ai-scientist-bench/ablation-bench获取。

英文摘要:

Language model agents are increasingly used to automate scientific research, yet evaluating their scientific contributions remains a challenge. A key mechanism to obtain such insights is through ablation experiments. To this end, we introduce AblationBench, a benchmark suite for evaluating agents on ablation planning tasks in empirical AI research. It includes two tasks: AuthorAblation, which helps authors propose ablation experiments based on a method section and contains 83 instances, and ReviewerAblation, which helps reviewers find missing ablations in a full paper and contains 350 instances. For both tasks, we develop LM-based judges that serve as an automatic evaluation framework. Our experiments with frontier LMs show that these tasks remain challenging, with the best-performing LM system identifying only 45% of the original ablations on average, below human-level performance. We observe an inverse performance trend between the author and reviewer tasks, which we attribute to differences in model grounding. Lastly, we analyze the limitations of current LMs on these tasks, and find that chain-of-thought prompting outperforms an agent-based approach. Our data is available on https://huggingface.co/collections/ai-coscientist/ablationbench, and our code is available on https://github.com/ai-scientist-bench/ablation-bench .

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑