智能体AI中随机、动态、流动的自主性:对作者身份、发明人身份和责任的影响
Stochastic, Dynamic, Fluid Autonomy in Agentic AI: Implications for Authorship, Inventorship, and Liability
AI总结:
本文探讨智能体AI的随机、动态和流动的自主性如何模糊人机贡献边界,导致传统法律框架在作者身份、知识产权和责任归属上失效,主张法律应将人机贡献视为功能等价。
摘要:
以OpenAI的DeepResearch为代表的智能体人工智能(AI)系统能够自主追求目标,通过隐式学习调整策略。与对用户提示作出反应的传统生成式AI不同,智能体AI主动编排复杂的工作流。它表现出随机、动态和流动的自主性:其步骤和输出概率性地变化(随机性),基于先前的交互而演化(动态性),并在人类定义的参数内以显著的独立性运行,适应上下文(流动性)。虽然这促进了能够生成独特综合创造性产出的复杂、协同进化的人机交互,但它也不可逆转地模糊了边界——人类和机器的贡献在交织的创造性过程中变得不可约化地纠缠在一起。因此,智能体AI对依赖清晰归属的法律框架提出了重大挑战:作者身份理论难以解开归属问题,知识产权体系难以容纳递归混合的新颖性,责任模型在控制点不断转移时因责任扩散而失效。核心问题不在于人类与机器贡献的法律处理,而在于根本上的不可映射性——在许多情况下无法准确地将特定创造性要素归属于任一方。追溯性地解析贡献变得不可行,基于来源应用不同标准也不切实际。因此,我们认为,法律和政策框架需要将人类和机器的贡献视为功能上等价的——这并非出于道德或经济原因,而是出于实用主义的必要性。
英文摘要:
Agentic Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems, exemplified by OpenAI's DeepResearch, autonomously pursue goals, adapting strategies through implicit learning. Unlike traditional generative AI, which is reactive to user prompts, agentic AI proactively orchestrates complex workflows. It exhibits stochastic, dynamic, and fluid autonomy: its steps and outputs vary probabilistically (stochastic), it evolves based on prior interactions (dynamic), and it operates with significant independence within human-defined parameters, adapting to context (fluid). While this fosters complex, co-evolutionary human-machine interactions capable of generating uniquely synthesized creative outputs, it also irrevocably blurs boundaries--human and machine contributions become irreducibly entangled in intertwined creative processes. Consequently, agentic AI poses significant challenges to legal frameworks reliant on clear attribution: authorship doctrines struggle to disentangle ownership, intellectual property regimes strain to accommodate recursively blended novelty, and liability models falter as accountability diffuses across shifting loci of control. The central issue is not the legal treatment of human versus machine contributions, but the fundamental unmappability--the practical impossibility in many cases--of accurately attributing specific creative elements to either source. When retroactively parsing contributions becomes infeasible, applying distinct standards based on origin becomes impracticable. Therefore, we argue, legal and policy frameworks may need to treat human and machine contributions as functionally equivalent--not for moral or economic reasons, but as a pragmatic necessity.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。