arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2503.04769cs.CY
收藏

应用人工智能工具提升立法参与:来自 Make.Org 和 MAPLE 的案例研究

Applications of Artificial Intelligence Tools to Enhance Legislative Engagement: Case Studies from Make.Org and MAPLE

Alicia Combaz, David Mas, Nathan Sanders, Matthew Victor

AI总结:

Make.org 与 MAPLE 合作探索 AI 在立法参与中的应用,总结出使信息获取、促进表达、支持审议和综合见解四个维度的经验,为政府与 NGO 提升民主效能提供部署建议。

摘要:

本文是 Make.org 和 Massachusetts Platform for Legislative Engagement (MAPLE) 之间的合作,这两个无党派的公民技术组织致力于构建新型 AI 部署以提升民主能力。Make.org 是欧洲的公民创新者,正在开发能够吸引数十万甚至数百万参与者的大规模在线参与平台。MAPLE 是美国的一个由志愿者领导的非政府组织,正在创建一个开源平台,以帮助选民更有效地理解和参与州立法过程。我们认为,AI 的辅助性整合能够对民主立法的公平性、效率和可及性产生有意义的影响。我们从设计、构建和运营集成 AI 的公民参与平台的经验中汲取了可推广的教训。我们讨论了受益于 AI 整合的立法参与的四个维度:(1) 使信息易于获取,(2) 促进表达,(3) 支持审议,以及 (4) 综合见解。我们介绍了来自当前、正在开发和计划中的 AI 驱动功能的经验,例如总结和组织政策信息,支持用户清晰表达他们的观点,以及综合民意中的共识和争议。我们概述了为公平部署这些工具需要克服哪些挑战,并讨论了 Make.org 和 MAPLE 如何实施并迭代改进这些概念,以使公民大会和决策更具参与性和响应性。我们比较了 Make.org 和 MAPLE 的方法,以及司法管辖区差异如何改变旨在改善民主的 AI 部署的风险与机遇。最后,我们为有意提升立法参与的政府和 NGO 提出了建议。

英文摘要:

This paper is a collaboration between Make.org and the Massachusetts Platform for Legislative Engagement (MAPLE), two non-partisan civic technology organizations building novel AI deployments to improve democratic capacity. Make.org, a civic innovator in Europe, is developing massive online participative platforms that can engage hundreds of thousands or even millions of participants. MAPLE, a volunteer-led NGO in the United States, is creating an open-source platform to help constituents understand and engage more effectively with the state law-making process. We believe that assistive integrations of AI can meaningfully impact the equity, efficiency, and accessibility of democratic legislating. We draw generalizable lessons from our experience in designing, building, and operating civic engagement platforms with AI integrations. We discuss four dimensions of legislative engagement that benefit from AI integrations: (1) making information accessible, (2) facilitating expression, (3) supporting deliberation, and (4) synthesizing insights. We present learnings from current, in development, and contemplated AI-powered features, such as summarizing and organizing policy information, supporting users in articulating their perspectives, and synthesizing consensus and controversy in public opinion. We outline what challenges needed to be overcome to deploy these tools equitably and discuss how Make.org and MAPLE have implemented and iteratively improved those concepts to make citizen assemblies and policymaking more participatory and responsive. We compare and contrast the approaches of Make.org and MAPLE, as well as how jurisdictional differences alter the risks and opportunities for AI deployments seeking to improve democracy. We conclude with recommendations for governments and NGOs interested in enhancing legislative engagement.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑