arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2503.03383cs.HCcs.CY
收藏

“直到我得到我的满足”:公众惩罚AI意愿中的开放问题

"Till I can get my satisfaction": Open Questions in the Public Desire to Punish AI

Eddie L. Ungless, Zachary Horne, Björn Ross

AI总结:

本文探讨了公众对AI造成危害后惩罚AI的期望这一未充分研究领域,综合多学科研究指出当前理解不足,并呼吁开展跨学科研究以避免法律惩罚与公众期望间出现“满足差距”。

摘要:

关于AI如何造成危害有无数例子,且有越来越多的证据表明,公众愿意将责任归咎于AI本身,无论这看起来多么“不合逻辑”。这引发了公众是否以及如何期望AI因此受到惩罚的问题。然而,公众对惩罚AI的期望在很大程度上未被充分探索。理解这些期望至关重要,因为除非公众的惩罚意愿得到满足,否则他们可能会感受到危害的持续影响。我们综合了心理学、人机与机器人交互、哲学与AI伦理以及法律的研究,以强调我们对这一问题的理解仍然不足。我们呼吁开展跨学科研究计划,以确立如何最好地满足AI危害的受害者,以免在对AI进行法律惩罚(或不惩罚)时未能达到公众期望,从而产生“满足差距”。

英文摘要:

There are countless examples of how AI can cause harm, and increasing evidence that the public are willing to ascribe blame to the AI itself, regardless of how "illogical" this might seem. This raises the question of whether and how the public might expect AI to be punished for this harm. However, public expectations of the punishment of AI have been vastly underexplored. Understanding these expectations is vital, as the public may feel the lingering effect of harm unless their desire for punishment is satisfied. We synthesise research from psychology, human-computer and -robot interaction, philosophy and AI ethics, and law to highlight how our understanding of this issue is still lacking. We call for an interdisciplinary programme of research to establish how we can best satisfy victims of AI harm, for fear of creating a "satisfaction gap" where legal punishment of AI (or not) fails to meet public expectations.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑