arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2502.19974physics.soc-ph
收藏

超越成本:绘制挪威青年对更具包容性能源转型的偏好

Beyond costs: Mapping Norwegian youth preferences for a more inclusive energy transition

Muhammad Shahzad Javed, Karin Fossheim, Paola Velasco-Herrejón, Nikolai Elias Koop, Matylda N. Guzik, Charles Dana Samuelson, Beate Seibt, Marianne Zeyringer

AI总结:

本研究通过挪威高中生研讨会发现,青年偏好海上风电和太阳能,重视能源独立、减排和生物多样性,而非成本最小化,揭示了模型优先级与青年观点的脱节。

摘要:

环境运动和气候罢工表明,青年感到自己被排除在正在进行的能源转型过程之外,这凸显了他们参与以实现社会可接受转型的关键必要性。这项跨学科研究聚焦于挪威电力系统,并与15至16岁的高中生开展了教育研讨会,以了解他们对净零能源系统的看法。研讨会分为三个部分,首先传播关于能源和气候的常识,随后进行互动活动,以探索和理解能源转型的各个方面。在三个不同时间间隔进行的问卷轮次评估了学生态度和社会-技术-经济偏好的变化。我们的研究结果显示,33%的学生倾向于将海上风电作为主要能源,而35%的学生选择将其与太阳能结合,这表明超过68%的学生认为海上风电是有利的。尽管32%的学生支持某种形式的陆上风力涡轮机,但对于在农业、森林和住宅区域建设风电场存在强烈分歧。偏好也显示出相当大的地区差异;太阳能设施在挪威南部和东南部受到青睐,而风电场则被建议用于中部和北部地区。学生们强调能源独立性,对需求响应表现出抵触,优先考虑减少排放和保护生物多样性,而非最小化电力成本。尽管成本最小化是大多数能源系统模型的核心,但青年认为它是最不重要的因素,这凸显了模型优先级与他们观点之间的脱节。

英文摘要:

Environmental movements and climate strikes have made it apparent that youth feel excluded from the ongoing energy transformation process, highlighting the crucial need for their engagement to achieve a socially accepted transition. This interdisciplinary study focuses on the Norwegian electricity system and involves conducting educational workshops with high school students aged 15 to 16 to ascertain their perspectives towards a net-zero energy system. The workshops were structured into three segments, starting with the dissemination of common knowledge about energy and climate, followed by interactive activities designed to explore and develop an understanding of various aspects of energy transition. Three rounds of questionnaires, administered at distinct time intervals, assessed changes in students' attitudes and socio-techno-economic preferences. Our findings show that 33\% of pupils favored exclusively offshore wind as a main energy source, while 35\% opted to combine it with solar energy, indicating that over 68\% viewed offshore wind as favorable. Although 32\% supported some form of land-based wind turbines, there was strong disagreement about wind parks in agricultural, forested, and residential areas. Preferences also exhibited considerable regional variation; solar installations were favored in southern and southeastern Norway, while wind farms were suggested for central and northern regions. Pupils emphasized energy independence, showed reluctance towards demand response, prioritized reducing emissions and preserving biodiversity over minimizing electricity costs. Despite cost-minimization being core to most energy system models, youth deemed it the least important factor, highlighting a disconnect between modeling priorities and their perspectives.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑