arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2502.14764cs.SIphysics.soc-ph
收藏

社会网络中将家庭视为实体的错觉

The illusion of households as entities in social networks

Izabel Aguiar, Philip S. Chodrow, Johan Ugander

AI总结:

本研究探讨了个体与家庭社会网络结构的关键差异,分析了网络选择对分析结果的影响,并提出了一套系统性建议以确定合适的网络表示方法。

摘要:

记录社区和村庄中人际连接的数据以多种方式被收集和分析,最常见的是作为个体网络或家庭网络。这两种网络在实质上可能存在显著差异。因此,选择研究哪种网络在研究设计和数据分析中都是一个重要的方面。在本研究中,我们考虑了家庭与个体社会网络结构之间的各种关键差异,以及网络不能互换使用的方式。除了形式化表示每个网络的选择外,我们还探讨了社会网络分析的结果如何随着选择研究个体还是家庭网络而改变——从确定网络是同配还是异配,到影响力最大化节点的排名。作为我们的主要贡献,我们借鉴相关工作,提出了一套系统性的建议,用于确定应研究哪种相关的网络表示。我们的建议包括评估一系列实体性标准,并将这些标准与社会动态中家庭层面的模式和规范的理论与观察联系起来:特别是,信息如何在家庭内传播,以及权力结构和性别角色如何影响这种传播。我们借鉴实体性错觉的定义,来识别将人群归入家庭无法满足这些标准或无法充分代表特定文化或实验情境的情况。鉴于社会网络数据被广泛用于研究社区,理解应研究哪种网络及其决策后果具有广泛影响。我们希望这项工作能为收集和研究社会网络数据的从业者和研究人员提供指导。

英文摘要:

Data recording connections between people in communities and villages are collected and analyzed in various ways, most often as either networks of individuals or as networks of households. These two networks can differ in substantial ways. The methodological choice of which network to study, therefore, is an important aspect in both study design and data analysis. In this work, we consider various key differences between household and individual social network structure, and ways in which the networks cannot be used interchangeably. In addition to formalizing the choices for representing each network, we explore the consequences of how the results of social network analysis change depending on the choice between studying the individual and household network -- from determining whether networks are assortative or disassortative to the ranking of influence-maximizing nodes. As our main contribution, we draw upon related work to propose a set of systematic recommendations for determining the relevant network representation to study. Our recommendations include assessing a series of entitativity criteria and relating these criteria to theories and observations about patterns and norms in social dynamics at the household level: notably, how information spreads within households and how power structures and gender roles affect this spread. We draw upon the definition of an illusion of entitativity to identify cases wherein grouping people into households does not satisfy these criteria or adequately represent given cultural or experimental contexts. Given the widespread use of social network data for studying communities, there is broad impact in understanding which network to study and the consequences of that decision. We hope that this work gives guidance to practitioners and researchers collecting and studying social network data.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑