arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2502.09618cs.CY
收藏

基于证据的AI政策的陷阱

Pitfalls of Evidence-Based AI Policy

Stephen Casper, David Krueger, Dylan Hadfield-Menell

AI总结:

本文指出过度追求高证据标准的AI监管可能导致风险被忽视或监管被拖延,提出应主动促进对AI风险的识别与研究,并讨论了15项监管目标及多国的改进机会。

摘要:

世界各国都在努力治理AI。然而,从技术角度来看,关于实现这一目标的最佳方式存在不确定性和分歧。与此同时,近期关于AI监管的辩论引发了对“基于证据的AI政策”的呼吁,强调将监管行动维持在较高的证据标准上。证据对政策制定具有不可替代的价值。然而,将监管行动维持在过高的证据标准上,会导致对某些风险的系统性忽视。在历史政策辩论中(例如,约1965年关于烟草和约1985年关于化石燃料的辩论),“基于证据的政策”这一修辞也是一种有充分先例的策略,用于淡化行动的紧迫性、拖延监管并保护行业利益。在此,我们认为如果目标是基于证据的AI政策,首要监管目标必须是积极促进识别、研究和审议AI风险的过程。我们讨论了15项旨在促进这一过程的监管目标,并表明巴西、加拿大、中国、欧盟、韩国、英国和美国都有大量机会采取进一步的证据寻求政策。

英文摘要:

Nations across the world are working to govern AI. However, from a technical perspective, there is uncertainty and disagreement on the best way to do this. Meanwhile, recent debates over AI regulation have led to calls for "evidence-based AI policy" which emphasize holding regulatory action to a high evidentiary standard. Evidence is of irreplaceable value to policymaking. However, holding regulatory action to too high an evidentiary standard can lead to systematic neglect of certain risks. In historical policy debates (e.g., over tobacco ca. 1965 and fossil fuels ca. 1985) "evidence-based policy" rhetoric is also a well-precedented strategy to downplay the urgency of action, delay regulation, and protect industry interests. Here, we argue that if the goal is evidence-based AI policy, the first regulatory objective must be to actively facilitate the process of identifying, studying, and deliberating about AI risks. We discuss a set of 15 regulatory goals to facilitate this and show that Brazil, Canada, China, the EU, South Korea, the UK, and the USA all have substantial opportunities to adopt further evidence-seeking policies.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑