arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2502.08548econ.GNq-fin.EC
收藏

区分电子商务平台的广告与市场功能:这是否能提升社会福利?

Separating Advertising and Marketplace Functions of E-commerce Platforms: Is it Social Welfare Enhancing?

University of Texas at Dallas(德克萨斯大学达拉斯分校);University of Denver(丹佛大学);Northwestern Polytechnical University(西北工业大学)

Zhe Zhang, Young Kwark, Srinivasan Raghunathan, Peng Wang

AI总结:

研究发现,将电子商务平台的广告功能分离会损害消费者利益,不一定提升社会福利。

摘要:

在消费者搜索结果的显要位置使用赞助产品列表,使传统上作为第三方卖家触达消费者市场场所的电子商务平台,成为卖家推广其产品的主要媒介。另一方面,监管机构对电子商务平台整合市场和广告功能表达了反垄断担忧;他们认为这种整合使平台和卖家受益,而消费者和社会受损,并已提出将广告功能与这些平台分离。我们证明,与监管机构的担忧相反,将广告功能从电子商务平台中分离出来,对卖家有利,对消费者不利,并不一定提升社会福利。我们发现的关键驱动因素是,一个仅依靠广告收入的独立广告公司,其经济激励与同时充当广告媒介的电子商务平台相比,相同或更小,即使两者在目标消费者方面能力相同。这是因为提高目标精度会通过削弱卖家之间的价格竞争而提升市场佣金,但会通过削弱对显要广告位置的竞争而损害广告收入。

英文摘要:

The use of sponsored product listings in prominent positions of consumer search results has made e-commerce platforms, which traditionally serve as marketplaces for third-party sellers to reach consumers, a major medium for those sellers to advertise their products. On the other hand, regulators have expressed anti-trust concerns about an e-commerce platform's integration of marketplace and advertising functions; they argue that such integration benefits the platform and sellers at the expense of consumers and society and have proposed separating the advertising function from those platforms. We show, contrary to regulators' concerns, that separating the advertising function from the e-commerce platform benefits the sellers, hurts the consumers, and does not necessarily benefit the social welfare. A key driver of our findings is that an independent advertising firm, which relies solely on advertising revenue, has same or lesser economic incentive to improve targeting precision than an e-commerce platform that also serves as the advertising medium, even if both have the same ability to target consumers. This is because an improvement in targeting precision enhances the marketplace commission by softening the price competition between sellers, but hurts the advertising revenue by softening the competition for prominent ad positions.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑