通过160万个LaTeX文件揭示科学团队中的隐性分工
Hidden Division of Labor in Scientific Teams Revealed Through 1.6 Million LaTeX Files
AI总结:
针对合著论文掩盖个人贡献的问题,本文通过分析160万篇论文LaTeX文件的作者特定宏命令构建大规模写作贡献数据集,揭示科学团队隐性分工,为信用分配政策提供参考。
摘要:
对个人贡献的认可是科学奖励体系的基础,但合著论文掩盖了谁做了什么。传统代理指标(作者顺序和职业阶段)会强化偏见,而贡献声明仍是自我报告的,且仅局限于部分期刊。我们通过分析200万科学家1991-2023年发表的160万篇论文LaTeX文件中的作者特定宏命令,构建了首个大规模写作贡献数据集。通过与自我报告声明(精度=0.87)、作者顺序模式、领域特定规范及Overleaf记录(斯皮尔曼相关系数ρ=0.6,p<0.05)的验证,证实了所创建数据的可靠性。利用明确的章节信息,我们揭示了科学团队内部的隐性分工:部分作者主要贡献于概念性章节(如引言和讨论),而另一些作者则专注于技术性章节(如方法和实验)。这些发现为科学团队中的隐性分工提供了首个大规模证据,挑战了传统的作者署名实践,并为信用分配的制度政策提供了参考。
英文摘要:
Recognition of individual contributions is fundamental to the scientific reward system, yet coauthored papers obscure who did what. Traditional proxies-author order and career stage-reinforce biases, while contribution statements remain self-reported and limited to select journals. We construct the first large-scale dataset on writing contributions by analyzing author-specific macros in LaTeX files from 1.6 million papers (1991-2023) by 2 million scientists. Validation against self-reported statements (precision = 0.87), author order patterns, field-specific norms, and Overleaf records (Spearman's rho = 0.6, p < 0.05) confirms the reliability of the created data. Using explicit section information, we reveal a hidden division of labor within scientific teams: some authors primarily contribute to conceptual sections (e.g., Introduction and Discussion), while others focus on technical sections (e.g., Methods and Experiments). These findings provide the first large-scale evidence of implicit labor division in scientific teams, challenging conventional authorship practices and informing institutional policies on credit allocation.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。