arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2502.03038cs.AIcs.CYcs.LG
收藏

智能的蛋糕与谁来做:一个AI类比及其对参与的意义

The Cake that is Intelligence and Who Gets to Bake it: An AI Analogy and its Implications for Participation

University of Bremen(不来梅大学);Meta;Technical University of Darmstadt(达姆施塔特工业大学);University of Hamburg(汉堡大学);DFKI(德国人工智能研究中心);Carnegie Mellon University(卡内基梅隆大学)

Martin Mundt, Anaelia Ovalle, Felix Friedrich, A Pranav, Subarnaduti Paul, Manuel Brack, Kristian Kersting, William Agnew

AI总结:

本文将“智能的蛋糕”类比扩展至AI系统完整生命周期,揭示各阶段技术基础与社会影响的交织关系,并提出跨学科参与建议。

摘要:

在图灵奖得主Yann LeCun提出的广为人知的类比中,机器智能被比作蛋糕——无监督学习构成基底,监督学习添加糖衣,强化学习则是顶部的樱桃。我们将这一“智能的蛋糕”类比从简单的结构隐喻扩展到AI系统的完整生命周期,延伸至原料采购(数据)、配方构思(指令)、烘焙过程(训练)以及蛋糕的品尝与销售(评估与分发)。借助我们的重新概念化,我们描述了每一步所蕴含的社会影响,以及这些影响如何受到机器学习内部统计假设的约束。尽管这些技术基础与社会影响深度交织,但它们往往被孤立地研究,从而形成了限制有意义参与的障碍。我们的重新概念化通过映射技术基础与社会结果相互作用的环节,为弥合这一鸿沟铺平了道路,并凸显了跨学科对话的机会。最后,我们针对隐喻性AI蛋糕生命周期的每个阶段提出了可操作的建议,使潜在的AI从业者、用户和研究人员能够以更高的意识和能力参与更广泛的AI讨论。

英文摘要:

In a widely popular analogy by Turing Award Laureate Yann LeCun, machine intelligence has been compared to cake - where unsupervised learning forms the base, supervised learning adds the icing, and reinforcement learning is the cherry on top. We expand this 'cake that is intelligence' analogy from a simple structural metaphor to the full life-cycle of AI systems, extending it to sourcing of ingredients (data), conception of recipes (instructions), the baking process (training), and the tasting and selling of the cake (evaluation and distribution). Leveraging our re-conceptualization, we describe each step's entailed social ramifications and how they are bounded by statistical assumptions within machine learning. Whereas these technical foundations and social impacts are deeply intertwined, they are often studied in isolation, creating barriers that restrict meaningful participation. Our re-conceptualization paves the way to bridge this gap by mapping where technical foundations interact with social outcomes, highlighting opportunities for cross-disciplinary dialogue. Finally, we conclude with actionable recommendations at each stage of the metaphorical AI cake's life-cycle, empowering prospective AI practitioners, users, and researchers, with increased awareness and ability to engage in broader AI discourse.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑