arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2502.02880cs.HC
收藏

教练而非拐杖:证据表明AI可以在减少努力的情况下提高写作能力

Coach not crutch: Evidence that AI can improve writing skill despite reducing effort

University of Pennsylvania(宾夕法尼亚大学);Harvard University(哈佛大学);Microsoft Research(微软研究院)

Benjamin Lira, Todd Rogers, Daniel G. Goldstein, Lyle Ungar, Angela L. Duckworth

AI总结:

该研究通过实验证明,AI写作工具在减少用户努力的同时,能够提升写作能力,挑战了传统认为AI会阻碍学习的观点。

摘要:

在一系列高功率的实证研究中,我们检验了这样一个直觉:通过节省努力,使用AI不可避免地会阻碍学习。首先,在一项全国具有代表性的调查中,大多数年轻人表达了使用AI会使人们更懒惰、能力下降的观点。接下来,在一个随机分配的实验中,我们给参与者上了关于专业写作最佳实践的教程,然后给一组人提供了一个AI写作工具,另一组人则自己练习写作。那些使用AI练习的人确实投入了更少的努力,但在没有AI的写作测试中写出了更好的求职信。在第二个实验中,通过更严谨的控制条件,使用AI提高了写作能力,比谷歌搜索求职信示例和建议或从有经验的人类编辑那里获得个性化反馈的效果更明显。第三个实验解释了这些学习增益,表明AI可以通过示例进行教学:那些查看过由AI工具修订的求职信但没有进一步练习的参与者,其写作能力提升与那些使用原始AI工具练习的参与者一样。总体而言,这些预注册的实验表明,AI可以在某些情况下对努力和学习速度产生相反的影响,使人们在减少努力的情况下学习更多。

英文摘要:

In a series of highly-powered empirical studies, we examine the intuition that by sparing effort, using AI inevitably hinders learning. First, in a nationally representative survey of young adults, the majority expressed the view that using AI makes people lazier and less capable. Next, in a random-assignment experiment, we gave participants a tutorial on best practices in professional writing, then provided one group with access to an AI writing tool and asked another to practice writing on their own. Those who practiced with AI indeed exerted less effort while practicing -- yet wrote better cover letters in no-AI writing tests. In a second experiment with more rigorous control conditions, access to AI improved writing more than either googling cover letter examples and tips or receiving personalized feedback on their practice letters from experienced human editors. A third experiment explained these learning gains by showing that AI can teach by example: participants who viewed a cover letter that had been revised by the AI tool but did no further practice improved their writing as much as those who practiced writing with the original AI tool. Collectively, these pre-registered experiments suggest that AI can exert opposing effects on effort and learning rate -- making it possible in at least some cases to work less and learn more.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑