撤稿论文中的被撤稿引用与自引:关于抄袭与虚假同行评审的对比研究
Retracted Citations and Self-citations in Retracted Publications: A Comparative Study of Plagiarism and Fake Peer Review
AI总结:
本研究基于Scopus和Retraction Watch数据库,对比分析了抄袭与虚假同行评审两类撤稿论文的被撤稿引用与自引趋势,发现抄袭论文获更多引用且撤稿更慢,自引在后续被撤稿引用中比例显著升高。
摘要:
被撤稿引用在学术界仍是一个重大隐患,因为它们尽管已被宣告无效,却仍在传播错误信息并损害科学文献的完整性。为分析被撤稿引用的影响,我们聚焦于两类撤稿类别:抄袭和虚假同行评审。数据集来源于Scopus,撤稿原因通过Retraction Watch数据库进行映射。撤稿趋势显示,抄袭案件呈现1.2倍的稳定平均增长,而虚假同行评审则表现出波动模式,平均增长5.5倍。尽管与虚假同行评审相比,抄袭类别的撤稿论文较少,但与抄袭相关的论文获得的引用量多出2.5倍。此外,抄袭论文的被撤稿引用总数比虚假同行评审论文高出1.8倍。在抄袭类别中,46%的被撤稿引用归因于抄袭;而在虚假同行评审类别中,53.6%的被撤稿引用归因于虚假同行评审。结果还表明,虚假同行评审案件比抄袭案件被识别和撤稿的速度更快。最后,自引在被撤稿论文的引用中占比很小,但在随后被撤稿的引用中,这两个类别的自引比例均显著升高。
英文摘要:
Retracted citations remain a significant concern in academia as they perpetuate misinformation and compromise the integrity of scientific literature despite their invalidation. To analyze the impact of retracted citations, we focused on two retraction categories: plagiarism and fake peer review. The data set was sourced from Scopus and the reasons for the retraction were mapped using the Retraction Watch database. The retraction trend shows a steady average growth in plagiarism cases of 1.2 times, while the fake peer review exhibits a fluctuating pattern with an average growth of 5.5 times. Although fewer papers are retracted in the plagiarism category compared to fake peer reviews, plagiarism-related papers receive 2.5 times more citations. Furthermore, the total number of retracted citations for plagiarized papers is 1.8 times higher than that for fake peer review papers. Within the plagiarism category, 46% of the retracted citations are due to plagiarism, while 53.6% of the retracted citations in the fake peer review category are attributed to the fake peer review. The results also suggest that fake peer review cases are identified and retracted more rapidly than plagiarism cases. Finally, self-citations constitute a small percentage of citations to retracted papers but are notably higher among citations that are later retracted in both the categories.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。