放射性碳汇总的新方法:使用泊松过程严格识别放射性碳样本发生率的变化/变点
A New Approach to Radiocarbon Summarisation: Rigorous Identification of Variations/Changepoints in the Occurrence Rate of Radiocarbon Samples using a Poisson Process
AI总结:
针对放射性碳“日期作为数据”分析中SPD方法统计无效的问题,提出基于非齐次泊松过程和贝叶斯RJ-MCMC框架的新方法,灵活重建样本发生率并严格识别统计显著的变点。
摘要:
估计过去事件频率或人口规模变化的一种常用范式是考虑在某个遗址随时间发现的考古/环境样本的发生率。这种“日期作为数据”方法的可靠性高度依赖于如何从底层样本中估计发生率,特别是当样本的日历年龄信息是通过放射性碳(14C)获得时。最常用的创建概率分布总和(SPD)的“14C日期作为数据”方法在统计上是不有效或不连贯的,并且可能提供高度误导性的推断。在此,我们提供了一种替代方法,该方法具有严格的统计基础,同时提供关于事件发生率潜在变点的有价值额外信息。此外,与当前的SPD替代方案不同,我们的汇总方法不限制用户使用预先指定的、僵化的汇总格式(例如指数或逻辑增长),而是灵活地适应日期本身。我们的方法论确保了更可靠的“14C日期作为数据”分析,使我们能够更好地评估和识别存在的潜在信号。我们将事件的发生建模为非齐次泊松过程,每个事件假设在考古/环境记录中留下一个放射性碳样本。然后,在完全贝叶斯框架内使用可逆跳跃马尔可夫链蒙特卡洛(RJ-MCMC)估计样本随时间的变化率。给定一组放射性碳样本,我们重建其发生率如何随日历时间变化,并识别该发生率是否包含统计上显著的变化,即事件发生率突然变化的特定时间。我们通过模拟研究和一个关于阿拉斯加和育空地区晚更新世巨型动物群变化的实际案例来说明我们的方法。
英文摘要:
A commonly-used paradigm to estimate changes in the frequency of past events or the size of populations is to consider the occurrence rate of archaeological/environmental samples found at a site over time. The reliability of such a "dates-as-data" approach is highly dependent upon how the occurrence rates are estimated from the underlying samples, particularly when calendar age information for the samples is obtained from radiocarbon (14C). The most frequently used "14C-dates-as-data" approach of creating Summed Probability Distributions (SPDs) is not statistically valid, or coherent, and can provide highly misleading inference. Here, we provide an alternative method with a rigorous statistical underpinning that also provides valuable additional information on potential changepoints in the rate of events. Furthermore, unlike current SPD alternatives, our summarisation approach does not restrict users to pre-specified, rigid, summary formats (e.g., exponential or logistic growth) but instead flexibly adapts to the dates themselves. Our methodology ensures more reliable "14C-dates-as-data" analyses, allowing us to better assess and identify potential signals present. We model the occurrence of events, each assumed to leave a radiocarbon sample in the archaeological/environmental record, as an inhomogeneous Poisson process. The varying rate of samples over time is then estimated within a fully-Bayesian framework using reversible-jump Markov Chain Monte Carlo (RJ-MCMC). Given a set of radiocarbon samples, we reconstruct how their occurrence rate varies over calendar time and identify if that rate contains statistically-significant changes, i.e., specific times at which the rate of events abruptly changes. We illustrate our method with both a simulation study and a practical example concerning late-Pleistocene megafaunal population changes in Alaska and Yukon.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。