Apple Silicon在ML训练中的性能分析
Profiling Apple Silicon Performance for ML Training
AI总结:
本文通过端到端训练多个LLM工作负载,对比了Apple Silicon与NVIDIA GPU的性能差异,发现Apple Silicon因页面错误、功耗和内核启动时间等系统级因素及BLAS性能差异而存在显著性能差距。
摘要:
Apple Silicon因其性能和在机器学习(ML)训练中的作用备受关注。与在ML训练中长期占主导地位的NVIDIA GPU不同,Apple Silicon在内存架构上有显著差异。它采用统一内存,将CPU和GPU内存集成在一起,而非分离的CPU内存和GPU VRAM。然而,很难判断统一内存是否意味着更多的性能优势。本文通过在不同内存场景下端到端训练多个大型语言模型(LLM)工作负载来调查性能差异。结果显示,Apple Silicon和NVIDIA GPU之间存在显著的性能差距。本文将这种差距归因于页面错误、功耗和内核启动时间等系统级因素。此外,还分析了基本线性代数子程序(BLAS)在NVIDIA GPU和Apple Silicon芯片上的性能差异,以进一步解释观察到的差距。
英文摘要:
Apple Silicon has attracted much attention for its performance and role in machine learning (ML) training. Unlike NVIDIA GPUs, which have traditionally dominated ML training, Apple Silicon has a significant difference in memory architecture. It uses Unified Memory, which integrates CPU and GPU memory instead of separate CPU memory and GPU VRAM. However, it is difficult to tell whether Unified Memory means more performance benefits. This paper investigates the performance differences by training several large language model (LLM) workloads end-to-end under different memory scenarios. The results show a significant performance gap between Apple Silicon and NVIDIA GPUs. This paper attributes this gap to system-level factors such as page faults, power consumption, and kernel launch time. In addition, the performance difference of basic linear algebra subprograms (BLAS) on the NVIDIA GPUs and Apple Silicon chips is analyzed to further explain the observed gap.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。