arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2501.10384cs.CYcs.HCcs.LG
收藏

Nirvana AI 治理:AI 政策制定如何重蹈三大旧谬误

Nirvana AI Governance: How AI Policymaking Is Committing Three Old Fallacies

U.C. Berkeley Law School(加州大学伯克利分校法学院);Technical University of Munich(慕尼黑工业大学)

Jiawei Zhang

AI总结:

本研究将“涅槃法”应用于 AI 治理,揭露了当前政策提案中“这山望着那山高”、“免费午餐”和“人可以是不同的”三大谬误,指出其因脱离现实比较和忽视固有成本而可能损害创新与社会进步。

摘要:

本研究将 Harold Demsetz 的“涅槃法”概念应用于 AI 治理领域,并揭穿了各种 AI 政策提案中常见的三大谬误——“这山望着那山高”、“免费午餐”以及“人可以是不同的”。借此,我揭露了当前 AI 监管提案中的根本性缺陷。首先,一些评论者直觉上认为人比机器更可靠,且政府在风险控制上比企业自我监管做得更好,但他们并未充分比较现状与拟议替代方案之间的差异。其次,在提出某些监管工具时,一些决策者和研究人员没有意识到,甚至掩盖了危害和成本也是其提案所固有的这一事实。第三,一些政策提案的提出是基于 AI 驱动的世界(AI 确实会导致某些风险)与完全理想化的世界(根本不存在风险)之间的错误比较。然而,恰当的做法应是将 AI 引发风险的世界与风险无处不在但人们仍能妥善应对的现实世界进行比较。这些谬误在 AI 治理中的盛行凸显了一个更广泛的问题:倾向于将潜在解决方案理想化,而不充分考虑其在现实世界中的影响。这种理想化可能导致监管提案不仅不切实际,而且对创新和社会进步具有潜在危害。

英文摘要:

This research applies Harold Demsetz's concept of the nirvana approach to the realm of AI governance and debunks three common fallacies in various AI policy proposals--"the grass is always greener on the other side," "free lunch," and "the people could be different." Through this, I expose fundamental flaws in the current AI regulatory proposal. First, some commentators intuitively believe that people are more reliable than machines and that government works better in risk control than companies' self-regulation, but they do not fully compare the differences between the status quo and the proposed replacements. Second, when proposing some regulatory tools, some policymakers and researchers do not realize and even gloss over the fact that harms and costs are also inherent in their proposals. Third, some policy proposals are initiated based on a false comparison between the AI-driven world, where AI does lead to some risks, and an entirely idealized world, where no risk exists at all. However, the appropriate approach is to compare the world where AI causes risks to the real world where risks are everywhere, but people can live well with these risks. The prevalence of these fallacies in AI governance underscores a broader issue: the tendency to idealize potential solutions without fully considering their real-world implications. This idealization can lead to regulatory proposals that are not only impractical but potentially harmful to innovation and societal progress.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑