一类满足聚合与非聚合原则的实用且可接受的社会福利排序:对聚合暴政与非聚合暴政的再审视
A Class of Practical and Acceptable Social Welfare Orderings That Satisfy the Principles of Aggregation and Non-Aggregation: Reexamination of the Tyrannies of Aggregation and Non-Aggregation
AI总结:
该研究针对社会选择中聚合与非聚合暴政的不可能性问题,提出定量、比率两种聚合原则,证明其与最低限度非聚合原则的兼容性差异,给出leximin规则新刻画,并提出一类优于标准秩折扣广义功利主义的社会福利排序。
摘要:
本文重新探讨了聚合暴政与非聚合暴政相关的不可能性结论。作者提出两种聚合原则——定量聚合与比率聚合,并探究其理论内涵。研究表明,在社会选择理论的标准公理假设下,定量聚合与最低限度非聚合互不兼容,而比率聚合与最低限度非聚合是兼容的。此外,本研究利用复制不变性和强版本非聚合原则,给出了leximin规则的一种新刻画。最后,作者提出了一类同时满足聚合与非聚合原则的实用且可接受的社会福利排序,这类排序相较于标准的秩折扣广义功利主义具有多重优势。
英文摘要:
This paper revisits impossibility results on the tyrannies of aggregation and non-aggregation. I propose two aggregation principles (quantitative aggregation and ratio aggregation) and investigate theoretical implications. As a result, I show that quantitative aggregation and minimal non-aggregation are incompatible while ratio aggregation and minimal non-aggregation are compatible under the assumption of standard axioms in social choice theory. Furthermore, this study provides a new characterization of the leximin rule by using replication invariance and the strong version of non-aggregation. Finally, I propose a class of practical and acceptable social welfare orderings that satisfy the principles of aggregation and non-aggregation, which has various advantages over the standard rank-discounted generalized utilitarianism.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。