生成式人工智能支持的渗透测试:Claude Opus、GPT-4与Copilot的对比
Generative Artificial Intelligence-Supported Pentesting: A Comparison between Claude Opus, GPT-4, and Copilot
AI总结:
本文分析Claude Opus、GPT-4和Copilot这三款主流通用GenAI工具在渗透测试执行标准(PTES)各阶段的表现,发现它们虽无法完全自动化渗透测试,但能提升特定任务效率,且Claude Opus表现最优。
摘要:
生成式人工智能(GenAI)的出现给社会带来了重大变革,可应用于众多领域,尤其在网络安全领域具有重要意义。在各类应用场景中,其在渗透测试(pentesting)或道德黑客流程中的应用备受关注。本文分析了主流通用GenAI工具——Claude Opus、ChatGPT的GPT-4及Copilot——在增强渗透测试执行标准(PTES)所定义的渗透测试流程方面的潜力。我们在受控虚拟化环境中对每个工具在PTES所有阶段的表现进行了评估。研究发现,这些工具虽无法完全自动化渗透测试流程,但能通过提升特定任务的效率和效果提供实质性支持。值得注意的是,所有工具均展现出实用性,而Claude Opus在实验场景中持续优于其他工具。
英文摘要:
The advent of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) has brought a significant change to our society. GenAI can be applied across numerous fields, with particular relevance in cybersecurity. Among the various areas of application, its use in penetration testing (pentesting) or ethical hacking processes is of special interest. In this paper, we have analyzed the potential of leading generic-purpose GenAI tools-Claude Opus, GPT-4 from ChatGPT, and Copilot-in augmenting the penetration testing process as defined by the Penetration Testing Execution Standard (PTES). Our analysis involved evaluating each tool across all PTES phases within a controlled virtualized environment. The findings reveal that, while these tools cannot fully automate the pentesting process, they provide substantial support by enhancing efficiency and effectiveness in specific tasks. Notably, all tools demonstrated utility; however, Claude Opus consistently outperformed the others in our experimental scenarios.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。