arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2501.04064cs.CY
收藏

审视反对AI存在性风险的流行论点:一项哲学分析

Examining Popular Arguments Against AI Existential Risk: A Philosophical Analysis

Torben Swoboda, Risto Uuk, Lode Lauwaert, Andrew P. Rebera, Ann-Katrien Oimann, Bartlomiej Chomanski, Carina Prunkl

AI总结:

本文系统重构并评估反对AI存在性风险的三种流行哲学论点,以弥补学术文献对怀疑立场严格分析不足的问题。

摘要:

关于人工智能(AI)及其潜在存在性风险的担忧已引起广泛关注,Geoffrey Hinton和Dennis Hassabis等人物主张采取强有力的保障措施,以防范灾难性后果。Nick Bostrom和Max Tegmark等著名学者通过探讨超级智能AI的长期影响,进一步推动了这一讨论。然而,这种存在性风险叙事面临批评,尤其是在大众媒体中;Timnit Gebru、Melanie Mitchell和Nick Clegg等学者认为,除其他问题外,这种叙事分散了人们对紧迫现实问题的注意力。尽管媒体报道广泛,但学术文献中对存在性风险论述的怀疑态度仍缺乏严格审视。为弥补这种不平衡,本文重构并评估了反对存在性风险观点的三种常见论点:分心论点(Distraction Argument)、人类脆弱性论点(Argument from Human Frailty)以及干预检查点论点(Checkpoints for Intervention Argument)。通过系统地重构和评估这些论点,本文旨在为更平衡的学术论述和进一步的AI研究提供基础。

英文摘要:

Concerns about artificial intelligence (AI) and its potential existential risks have garnered significant attention, with figures like Geoffrey Hinton and Dennis Hassabis advocating for robust safeguards against catastrophic outcomes. Prominent scholars, such as Nick Bostrom and Max Tegmark, have further advanced the discourse by exploring the long-term impacts of superintelligent AI. However, this existential risk narrative faces criticism, particularly in popular media, where scholars like Timnit Gebru, Melanie Mitchell, and Nick Clegg argue, among other things, that it distracts from pressing current issues. Despite extensive media coverage, skepticism toward the existential risk discourse has received limited rigorous treatment in academic literature. Addressing this imbalance, this paper reconstructs and evaluates three common arguments against the existential risk perspective: the Distraction Argument, the Argument from Human Frailty, and the Checkpoints for Intervention Argument. By systematically reconstructing and assessing these arguments, the paper aims to provide a foundation for more balanced academic discourse and further research on AI.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑