在知识产权法阴影下解构 NFT
Unwinding NFTs in the Shadow of IP Law
AI总结:
本文反驳以动产法或买卖法规制 NFT 的主张,论证现行知识产权法更能应对公地与反公地悲剧、承接社区规范及许可协议,并平衡创新、竞争与消费者保护。
摘要:
在围绕非同质化代币(NFT)的知识产权(IP)纠纷激增之际,一些学者主张适用动产法或买卖法来规制 NFT 的铸造与交易,认为知识产权法过度阻碍了 NFT 市场的发展。本文反驳这些主张,并论证现行知识产权制度是治理不断演进的 NFT 市场最合适的监管框架。与动产法或买卖法相比,知识产权法能够更有效地应对 NFT 市场中的公地悲剧和反公地悲剧等挑战。NFT 社区也在现有知识产权法的基础上发展出自身的规范与许可协议,以规制共享资源。此外,知识产权制度兼具静态与动态的制度设计,能够有效平衡创新、公平竞争和消费者保护等多种政策关切,而这些是替代性方案难以提供的。
英文摘要:
Amid the surge of intellectual property (IP) disputes surrounding non-fungible tokens (NFTs), some scholars have advocated for the application of personal property or sales law to regulate NFT minting and transactions, contending that IP laws unduly hinder the development of the NFT market. This Article counters these proposals and argues that the existing IP system stands as the most suitable regulatory framework for governing the evolving NFT market. Compared to personal property or sales law, IP laws can more effectively address challenges such as tragedies of the commons and anticommons in the NFT market. NFT communities have also developed their own norms and licensing agreements upon existing IP laws to regulate shared resources. Moreover, the IP regimes, with both static and dynamic institutional designs, can effectively balance various policy concerns, such as innovation, fair competition, and consumer protection, which alternative proposals struggle to provide.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。