家长主义与深思熟虑:关于制定正式规则的实验
Paternalism and Deliberation: An Experiment on Making Formal Rules
AI总结:
通过炸弹风险诱发任务实验,研究强制性等待期作为软家长主义政策是否替代硬性限制,以及延迟决策是否更受尊重,发现等待期是附加限制而非替代。
摘要:
强制性等待期已被用于医疗程序、枪支购买和其他高风险决策。这些软家长主义政策是否是更严格限制的替代品?延迟决策是否更受尊重?在一项一般人群调查实验中,选择架构师为面临高风险炸弹风险诱发任务的决策者制定规则。实验处理变量是决策时间:当场或一天后,以及初始决策是否可以修改。选择架构师设定决策者风险承担的上限;在一个处理中,他们还可以实施强制性等待期。外生深思熟虑对上限于无影响;等价检验(TOST)和贝叶斯分析($\text{BF}_{01} \approx 12$)为无效应提供了强有力的正面证据。内生规定的等待期是附加限制,并不替代上限。选择架构师相信,随着时间的推移,平均决策者将承担更少的风险,并且——由于选择架构师理想点的分布——更接近选择架构师的主观理想选择;由此导致的预测误差减少很小。软和硬的家长主义工具并非替代品:等待期被用作附加限制。
英文摘要:
Mandatory waiting periods have been instituted for medical procedures, gun purchases, and other high-stakes decisions. Are these softly paternalistic policies substitutes for harder restrictions, and are delayed decisions more respected? In a general population survey experiment, Choice Architects make rules for decision-makers facing a high-stakes Bomb Risk Elicitation Task. Treatments vary when the decision is made: on the spot or after one day, and whether the initial decision can be revised. Choice Architects set a cap on the decision-maker's risk taking; in one treatment, they can additionally implement a mandatory waiting period. Exogenous deliberation has no effect on the cap; equivalence testing (TOST) and Bayesian analysis ($\text{BF}_{01} \approx 12$) provide strong positive evidence for the absence of an effect. Endogenously prescribed waiting periods are add-on restrictions that do not substitute for the cap. Choice Architects believe that, with time, the average decision-maker will take less risk and -- because of the distribution of Choice Architects' bliss points -- come closer to Choice Architects' subjective ideal choice; the resulting reduction in forecasted errors is small. Soft and hard paternalistic instruments are not substitutes: waiting periods are deployed as add-on restrictions.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。