arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2501.00488cs.LO
收藏

不完整描述与限定性确定性

Incomplete Descriptions and Qualified Definiteness

Bartosz Więckowski

AI总结:

本文通过将罗素唯一性条款中的同一性替换为限定同一性,形式化地刻画了定冠词宽松使用下的不完整限定描述,并借助证明论语义学给出严格与宽松确定性的统一说明。

摘要:

根据罗素的观点,在限定描述“the F”中,定冠词“the”的严格使用涉及唯一性;如果存在多个F,则“the F”的使用较为宽松,此时应优先使用不定描述“an F”。我们给出对“the F is G”这类结构的说明,其中定冠词被宽松使用(因此“the F”是不完整的),本质上是通过用限定同一性概念替换罗素唯一性条款中通常的同一性概念,即“a在所有Q方面与b相同”,其中Q是谓词集合P的子集。这一修改为我们提供了限定性的唯一性和确定性概念。当Q = P时,限定确定性陈述“the Q-unique F is G”是严格的;当Q是P的真子集时,则是宽松的。该说明通过证明论和证明论语义学在形式上得到精确表述。

英文摘要:

According to Russell, strict uses of the definite article 'the' in a definite description 'the F' involve uniqueness; in case there is more than one F, 'the F' is used somewhat loosely, and an indefinite description 'an F' should be preferred. We give an account of constructions of the form 'the F is G' in which the definite article is used loosely (and in which 'the F' is, therefore, incomplete), essentially by replacing the usual notion of identity in Russell's uniqueness clause with the notion of qualified identity, i.e., 'a is the same as b in all Q-respects', where Q is a subset of the set of predicates P. This modification gives us qualified notions of uniqueness and definiteness. A qualified definiteness statement 'the Q-unique F is G' is strict in case Q = P and loose in case Q is a proper subset of P. The account is made formally precise in terms of proof theory and proof-theoretic semantics.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑