arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2412.20873q-bio.NC
收藏

神经现象结构主义与计算语境的作用

Neurophenomenal Structuralism and the Role of Computational Context

Marlo Paßler, Adrien Doerig

AI总结:

本文提出计算语境对神经现象结构主义至关重要,并通过敏感性、组织性、利用性和语境化四个标准论证只有嵌入适当计算语境的激活结构才能作为意识内容的神经相关物,从而修正现有结构主义理论的不足。

摘要:

神经现象结构主义主张,意识体验是以关系方式定义的,其现象结构由神经结构所镜像。尽管这一进路为识别意识内容(NCCCs)的神经相关物提供了一个有前景的框架,但我们认为,仅仅在神经结构与现象结构之间建立结构对应关系是不够的。本文强调计算语境在决定神经结构内容方面的关键作用。我们引入四个标准——敏感性、组织性、利用性和语境化——来评估哪些神经结构是可行的NCCC候选者。这些标准突出表明,神经结构要有意义地镜像现象结构,就必须被主动利用,并能够以保持结构的方式影响行为。我们的分析表明,解剖学神经结构和因果神经结构无法满足某些标准,而激活结构则能够满足,前提是它们被嵌入适当的计算语境之中。我们的发现挑战了局部结构主义理论和丰富的全局结构主义理论,因为它们忽视了计算语境的内容构成作用,导致所提出的NCCC无法充分解释意识内容。我们得出结论:将计算语境纳入其中对于任何关于意识的结构主义说明都是必不可少的,因为它决定了神经激活空间内维度的性质,并由此决定了意识体验的内容。

英文摘要:

Neurophenomenal structuralism posits that conscious experiences are defined relationally and that their phenomenal structures are mirrored by neural structures. While this approach offers a promising framework for identifying neural correlates of contents of consciousness (NCCCs), we argue that merely establishing structural correspondences between neural and phenomenal structures is insufficient. This paper emphasizes the critical role of computational context in determining the content of neural structures. We introduce four criteria - Sensitivity, Organization, Exploitation, and Contextualization - to evaluate which neural structures are viable NCCC candidates. These criteria highlight that, for neural structures to meaningfully mirror phenomenal structures they have to be actively exploited and be able to influence behavior in a structure-preserving way. Our analysis demonstrates that anatomical and causal neural structures fail to meet certain criteria, whereas activation structures can, provided they are embedded within the appropriate computational context. Our findings challenge both local and rich global structuralist theories for overlooking the content-constituting role of computational context, leading to proposed NCCCs that fail to fully account for conscious content. We conclude that incorporating computational context is essential for any structuralist account of consciousness, as it determines the nature of dimensions within neural activation spaces and, consequently, the content of conscious experiences.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑