arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2412.10643stat.OTcs.LGstat.ME
收藏

科学实在论与反实在论:走向共同立场

Scientific Realism vs. Anti-Realism: Toward a Common Ground

University of California, Davis(加州大学戴维斯分校)

Hanti Lin

AI总结:

本文针对科学实在论与反实在论的僵局,提出以统计学和机器学习见解为基础的共同立场,要求双方证立各自的 Ockham's razor 并提供非循环解释,从而揭示分歧的认识论根源。

摘要:

科学实在论与反实在论之间的辩论仍处于僵局,使得和解似乎毫无希望。然而,仍有重要工作待做:探索共同立场,哪怕只是为了揭示更深层的分歧点,理想情况下还能使辩论双方受益。我提出了这样一条共同立场。具体而言,许多反实在论者(如工具主义者)尚未认真响应 Sober 的呼吁,即通过正面论述来证立其偏好的 Ockham's razor 版本。同时,实在论者面临类似挑战:需对其 Ockham's razor 版本如何与真理相联系提供非循环的解释。我提出的共同立场为双方应对这些挑战提供了解决方案;关键在于利用“每个人都重视某些真理”这一理念,并借鉴研究科学推断的科学领域(即统计学与机器学习)的见解。此共同立场还揭示了实在论辩论中不可调和性所特有的认识论根源。

英文摘要:

The debate between scientific realism and anti-realism remains at a stalemate, making reconciliation seem hopeless. Yet, important work remains: exploring a common ground, even if only to uncover deeper points of disagreement and, ideally, to benefit both sides of the debate. I propose such a common ground. Specifically, many anti-realists, such as instrumentalists, have yet to seriously engage with Sober's call to justify their preferred version of Ockham's razor through a positive account. Meanwhile, realists face a similar challenge: providing a non-circular explanation of how their version of Ockham's razor connects to truth. The common ground I propose addresses these challenges for both sides; the key is to leverage the idea that everyone values some truths and to draw on insights from scientific fields that study scientific inference -- namely, statistics and machine learning. This common ground also isolates a distinctively epistemic root of the irreconcilability in the realism debate.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑