arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2412.08352cs.SE
收藏

面向微服务应用的静态分析架构恢复工具比较

Comparison of Static Analysis Architecture Recovery Tools for Microservice Applications

Simon Schneider, Alexander Bakhtin, Xiaozhou Li, Jacopo Soldani, Antonio Brogi, Tomas Cerny, Riccardo Scandariato, Davide Taibi

AI总结:

本研究通过多源文献综述识别出13款面向微服务应用的静态架构恢复工具,对其中9款的检测能力进行对比,发现最优工具F1值为0.86,进一步组合4款工具可将F1值提升至0.91。

摘要:

架构恢复工具可帮助软件工程师在软件开发生命周期的所有阶段掌握软件系统的结构概览。这对微服务应用而言尤为重要,因为这类应用由多个相互交互的微服务组成,使得架构监管更具挑战性。学术文献与灰色文献中已提出多种架构恢复(也称为架构重构)的工具与技术,但目前尚无对其准确性的综述与比较。\n 本文呈现了一项多源文献综述的结果,研究目标为识别面向微服务应用的架构恢复工具,并对比所识别工具的架构恢复准确率。我们聚焦于静态工具,因为这类工具可集成到快节奏的CI/CD流水线中。研究从文献中识别出13款此类工具,其中9款可被执行,并针对其检测不同系统特征的能力进行比较。表现最佳的工具整体F1值达0.86。此外,本研究还探究了结合多款工具以提升恢复正确率的可能性,得到一个由4款独立工具组成的组合方案,其F1值可达0.91。\n 注册报告:本研究的方法论已通过同行评审,被MSR'24接收为注册报告,对应arXiv编号为arXiv:2403.06941。

英文摘要:

Architecture recovery tools help software engineers obtain an overview of the structure of their software systems during all phases of the software development life cycle. This is especially important for microservice applications because they consist of multiple interacting microservices, which makes it more challenging to oversee the architecture. Various tools and techniques for architecture recovery (also called architecture reconstruction) have been presented in academic and gray literature sources, but no overview and comparison of their accuracy exists. This paper presents the results of a multivocal literature review with the goal of identifying architecture recovery tools for microservice applications and a comparison of the identified tools' architectural recovery accuracy. We focused on static tools since they can be integrated into fast-paced CI/CD pipelines. 13 such tools were identified from the literature and nine of them could be executed and compared on their capability of detecting different system characteristics. The best-performing tool exhibited an overall F1-score of 0.86. Additionally, the possibility of combining multiple tools to increase the recovery correctness was investigated, yielding a combination of four individual tools that achieves an F1-score of 0.91. Registered report: The methodology of this study has been peer-reviewed and accepted as a registered report at MSR'24: arXiv:2403.06941

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑