arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2412.08087cs.CYcs.DL
收藏

从分化到统一:1990-2021年计算社会科学兴起的大规模研究

From Division to Unity: A Large-Scale Study on the Emergence of Computational Social Science, 1990-2021

Honglin Bao, Jiawei Zhang, Mingxuan Cao, James A. Evans

AI总结:

本研究通过训练CSS分类器分析1990-2021年1100万篇论文,揭示了计算社会科学兴起的两个关键拐点、身份认同演化及学科同质化规律,展现了新学科从分化到融合的动态过程。

摘要:

我们对计算社会科学(Computational Social Science,CSS)——一门利用计算方法解决社会科学问题的交叉学科——的兴起及其对相邻社会科学的影响开展了全面研究。我们利用聚焦CSS的会议期刊的论文训练了一个鲁棒的CSS分类器,并将其应用于1990年至2021年间的1100万篇论文。分析得出三项关键发现。第一,CSS的兴起存在两个关键拐点。第一个拐点出现在2005年左右,当时心理学、政治学和社会学开始涉足CSS;第二个拐点约出现在2014年,经济学最终加入这一趋势,目前社会学是与CSS结合最紧密的学科。第二,利用先进transformer模型构建的年度知识嵌入密度,我们观察到CSS最初缺乏统一的身份认同。但从21世纪初到2014年,它开始形成独特的集群,在CSS与其他社会科学(尤其是政治学和社会学)之间建立了边界。2014年后,这些边界逐渐消失,CSS与社会科学的融合日益加深。第三,共通的数据驱动方法使不同学科的CSS论文趋于同质化,受CSS和因果识别的共同影响,政治学和经济学的一致性最高;然而,社会学、心理学和政治学领域的非CSS论文则差异越来越大。综上,这些发现揭示了新学科在现有知识格局中兴起时的分化与统一动态。CSS演化的在线演示可访问https://evolution-css.netlify.app/

英文摘要:

We present a comprehensive study on the emergence of Computational Social Science (CSS) - an interdisciplinary field leveraging computational methods to address social science questions - and its impact on adjacent social sciences. We trained a robust CSS classifier using papers from CSS-focused venues and applied it to 11 million papers spanning 1990 to 2021. Our analysis yielded three key findings. First, there were two critical inflections in the rise of CSS. The first occurred around 2005 when psychology, politics, and sociology began engaging with CSS. The second emerged in approximately 2014 when economics finally joined the trend. Sociology is currently the most engaged with CSS. Second, using the density of yearly knowledge embeddings constructed by advanced transformer models, we observed that CSS initially lacked a cohesive identity. From the early 2000s to 2014, however, it began to form a distinct cluster, creating boundaries between CSS and other social sciences, particularly in politics and sociology. After 2014, these boundaries faded, and CSS increasingly blended with the social sciences. Third, shared data-driven methods homogenized CSS papers across disciplines, with politics and economics showing the most alignment due to the combined influence of CSS and causal identification. Nevertheless, non-CSS papers in sociology, psychology, and politics became more divergent. Taken together, these findings highlight the dynamics of division and unity as new disciplines emerge within existing knowledge landscapes. A live demo of CSS evolution can be found in https://evolution-css.netlify.app/

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑